MAY 08, 2018 11:00 PM PDT

Adjusting Pricing Model for Novel Cancer Treatments

WRITTEN BY: Mauri Brueggeman

Current cancer drug or therapy pricing models have been based on a “one drug-one price” model but is that the best pricing model for the future of cancer drugs?  Cancer treatments are incredibly costly and depending on the diagnosis, more or fewer resources are spent on the research to bring a drug to market.  Part of that premise is to fortify the “one drug-one price” model by choosing to research drugs for the diseases that affect the most people.  This leads to increased revenue from the larger patient population utilizing that medicine when it gets to the market.  Additionally, drugs that work for one cancer or disease may work for another with lesser gains but still provide benefit to patients.  One novel pricing model, known as “indicator-based pricing”, is causing many to stop and ask about changing the way medicines are priced; essentially, the indicator-based pricing model suggests it could better align reimbursement (on the insurance side) or cost (on the pharmaceutical side) with value and market size.

Many drugs currently on the market are approved by the FDA to treat different diseases.  According to a 2015 Institute for Clinical and Economic Review Report, “…despite different clinical benefit across indications, the reimbursement system in the United States, rooted in a history of pricing by dosing unit, assigns a single uniform price to a drug, no matter how it is used.” 

Novartis created a chimeric antigen receptor T-cell (CAR T-cell) therapy, Kymriah, for pediatric acute lymphoblastic leukemia (ALL); the drug was approved in August 2017 for patients under the age of 25.  It was recently approved again for large B-cell lymphoma.  According to some reports, Novartis is beginning to utilize an indicator-based pricing model for this therapy.  For large B-cell lymphoma patients, the one-time treatment price is nearly $375,000, whereas the price for a pediatric ALL patient adds $100,000 to that price. 

In March of 2017, a group of subject matter experts from the biopharma and insurance industries, oncology practitioners, patients and patient advocates, and healthcare organizations were convened for the President’s Cancer Panel as part of the National Cancer Program.  This group discussed strategies for sustainable access to high-value cancer drugs.  All participants could agree that policies and practices should be developed to help lower the cost burden of treatments for patients, despite having differing priorities. 

This is a controversial topic with proponents for and against this new pricing model.  There is certainly a cost containment challenge and begs the question, “Who benefits from this new model?” Technology, personalized medicine, piles of data, better avenues for diagnosis, and a continued rise in healthcare costs for all requires new ideas and attempts at sustainability.  The more opportunity there is to put ideas on the table, the more potential to create something that works.

DrugAbacus is a website where anyone can compare a drug’s actual price to its value; the site’s creator is Peter Bach of Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center in New York.  Dr. Bach speaks about this issue in the video below. 

Sources: President’s Cancer Panel, Nature Reviews Clinical Oncology, Oncologist, Business Insider, PharmExec.com, DrugAbacus

 

About the Author
  • Mauri S. Brueggeman is a Medical Laboratory Scientist and Educator with a background in Cytogenetics and a Masters in Education from the University of Minnesota. She has worked in the clinical laboratory, taught at the University of Minnesota, and been in post secondary healthcare education administration. She is passionate about advances and leadership in science, medicine, and education.
You May Also Like
OCT 05, 2020
Cancer
Fighting mitochondrial terminal exhaustion
OCT 05, 2020
Fighting mitochondrial terminal exhaustion
New findings reported in Nature Immunology highlight how the tumor microenvironment attacks the mitochondria of T l ...
OCT 28, 2020
Cancer
Protecting the Head and Neck from Off Target Radiation
OCT 28, 2020
Protecting the Head and Neck from Off Target Radiation
Radiotherapy alone or with chemotherapy is the go-to treatment for head and neck cancers. Unfortunately, head and neck t ...
OCT 26, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Fighting mesothelioma with gold nanotubes
OCT 26, 2020
Fighting mesothelioma with gold nanotubes
New research published in the journal Small details how gold nanotubes could be used to treat mesothelioma cancer. ...
NOV 06, 2020
Drug Discovery & Development
Anti-depressant Shows Promise in Treating Childhood Cancer
NOV 06, 2020
Anti-depressant Shows Promise in Treating Childhood Cancer
Researchers from Sweden and the US have found that a commonly prescribed antidepressant may help stop the growth of a ca ...
NOV 18, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
Choosing an NGS workflow: What are you looking for?
NOV 18, 2020
Choosing an NGS workflow: What are you looking for?
  It’s easy to be overwhelmed by the number of workflows that are available for NGS. How do you choose? While ...
NOV 23, 2020
Cancer
Platelets May Protect Cancer Against PD-1 Therapies
NOV 23, 2020
Platelets May Protect Cancer Against PD-1 Therapies
One of cancer’s greatest tools is its ability to manipulate the immune system. Many cancer therapies have arisen t ...
Loading Comments...