APR 30, 2014 12:00 AM PDT

Long-Held Biodiversity Theory Challenged With New Study

WRITTEN BY: Jen Ellis
To conservationists, the so-called "equilibrium theory of island biogeography" is a standard assumption used when predicting the effects of human activities on nearby biosystems. In essence, the theory assumes that when a previously natural landscape has been altered by human activity - whether through development or through farming - that typical paths of migration of wildlife are cut off.

The effect is to limit or deny access to food supplies and areas of shelter. Potentially, it affects breeding habits as well. Multiplied over a larger area, this effect can drive species to extinction unless a reserve habitat area is created for them - the protected "island" in the theory.

This assumption draws a sharp line between the biodiversity in the human-influenced and natural habitats - and the theory has worked relatively well in certain areas. The theory also leads to dire predictions for planet Earth, with an inevitable clash between the resources required to feed and support an estimated 9 billion people by 2050 and the species that are displaced by human interaction.

However, a research team from Stanford University suggests in a recent study that the dividing line may not be so sharp, and the predictions may be too dire. Their study was published in the latest issue of Nature.

According to the team, the island theory doesn't always hold true because the island assumption itself doesn't always hold true. The island theory was developed using literal islands in lake or ocean environments, and does not take into account the alternate pathways available within land-based habitats. The researchers suggest that a more holistic approach to management of farmland and habitats can better balance the needs of both humans and wildlife, and keep up the levels of biodiversity.

To test these approaches, the group studied a variety of bats that are extremely sensitive to loss of a forest habitat. For contrast, the bats were studied in a mixed area of coffee plantations and forest located in Costa Rica and also in Panamanian islands located within a lake.

The theory performed as expected on the island population of bats, but it did a poor job of predicting the Costa Rican results. The island theory predicted that the coffee plantations could not support any bat species - but the actual reduction in species was minimized. Forested areas and reserves were able to support 23-28 bat species, while coffee plantations supported 18 species.

This finding should not imply that loss of any bat species, or any species at all, is trivial. However, it does suggest that biodiversity can be achieved in cooperation with development by using proper management techniques. Instead of isolating and dividing, we may be able to maintain biodiversity by integrating wildlife and development needs.

The authors noted that not only can the island theory predict excessive extinction, it can also fail to take into account novel species that do well in the altered environment. The overall message is that both humans and wildlife can benefit from a new theory that takes into account adaptability in land-based habitats.
About the Author
You May Also Like
JAN 22, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Indigneous lands represent more than just conservation opportunities
JAN 22, 2021
Indigneous lands represent more than just conservation opportunities
We’ve heard it before: the lands occupied and stewarded by Indigenous peoples are crucial biodiversity hotspots. N ...
JAN 29, 2021
Earth & The Environment
The surprising sex lives of lichen
JAN 29, 2021
The surprising sex lives of lichen
Just like eavesdropping neighbors, scientists from Quebec's Université-Laval are peeping in on the shocking s ...
FEB 18, 2021
Plants & Animals
Scientists Stumble Upon Life Below Ice Shelf
FEB 18, 2021
Scientists Stumble Upon Life Below Ice Shelf
In a discovery touted as a "fortunate accident," scientists from the British Antarctic Survey (BAS) stumbled u ...
MAR 26, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Iconic Bald Eagles are Thriving
MAR 26, 2021
Iconic Bald Eagles are Thriving
Once dangerously on the brink of extinction, bald eagle populations are thriving throughout the lower 48 states of the U ...
MAR 26, 2021
Plants & Animals
A Massive 17-Year Cicada Swarm will Emerge Soon
MAR 26, 2021
A Massive 17-Year Cicada Swarm will Emerge Soon
The east coast is preparing for one of nature’s greatest spectacles. A gigantic swarm of periodical cicadas is due ...
APR 01, 2021
Plants & Animals
Scientists Solve Sea Lion Cancer Mystery
APR 01, 2021
Scientists Solve Sea Lion Cancer Mystery
For more than thirty years, scientists have tried to solve the mystery of the high prevalence of cancer among wild Calif ...
Loading Comments...