MAY 13, 2014 12:00 AM PDT

To Frack or Not to Frack, That is the Question

WRITTEN BY: Jen Ellis
Fracking, or the process of opening fissures in rock formations through high-pressure injection of fluids, has opened a raging risk/reward argument.

On one side are energy advocates, who hail fracking as a boon to the oil and gas industry - opening access to previously inaccessible or uneconomic deposits of oil and natural gas. On the other side, environmentalists argue that fracking causes damage to natural systems in several ways - generating huge amounts of waste fluids, increasing the environmental impact of transport, and creating potential seismic damage trough unnatural manipulation of rock formations.

Scientists at the recent Seismological Society of America (SSA) conference suggested that the underground injection disposal process of wastewater from fracking might be creating a higher earthquake risk than previously thought.

Seismologists have little to work on in this field, especially in areas such as the Midwestern and Southwestern United States, since there has been limited mapping of fault lines in some of the fracking areas. There is also no consensus method of evaluating the risk that a fracking operation poses to seismic activity, and over what distance it poses a risk (although recent research does indicate disposal wells can affect earthquake faults that are miles away from the site).
Both sides offer some supporting information.

Operations were suspended in early 2012 at a site in Youngstown, Ohio operated by D&L energy after an unusual round of earthquakes in the area were reported in 2011. It had been suggested that wastewater disposal of the fracking process may have been linked to the tremors.

Later in 2012, the National Research Council issued a report regarding fracking and seismic activity, confirming that "at one location in the world" the fracking process was responsible "for small felt seismic events". However, the ultimate conclusion was that more research was needed to study the link between fracking and seismic activity.

Art McGarr, a geophysicist with the USGS (US Geological Survey), said during the SSA proceedings that in the majority of cases, there does not appear to be seismic effects from wells that are injecting wastewater from fracking processes. Even so, he continued, a few wells have been linked to subsequent earthquakes, and the process is likely to be aggravated with higher volumes and injection rates of fracking wastewater.

The seismologists acknowledge that they do not know how these potential hazards can be removed. In all likelihood, they probably can be mitigated somewhat but not eliminated. This brings us back to the question of risk vs. reward.

Currently there is significant anecdotal evidence, but little actual evidence. Those siding with the energy industry argue there is not enough solid evidence to halt successful fracking operations, and that the economic and geopolitical effects would be significantly harmful. Environmentalists argue that this is not a risk worth taking.

We welcome a comprehensive study of the issue to determine the connection between seismic activity and fracking - and if there is a connection, to determine what amount of harm it causes.
About the Author
You May Also Like
JAN 11, 2021
Earth & The Environment
The exorbitant cost of flooding
JAN 11, 2021
The exorbitant cost of flooding
New research published recently in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences reports on the econo ...
JAN 18, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Another record we didn't want: 2020 was the hottest year yet
JAN 18, 2021
Another record we didn't want: 2020 was the hottest year yet
It will likely come as no surprise that 2020 held another record that we wish it didn’t: hottest year on record. W ...
JAN 22, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Indigneous lands represent more than just conservation opportunities
JAN 22, 2021
Indigneous lands represent more than just conservation opportunities
We’ve heard it before: the lands occupied and stewarded by Indigenous peoples are crucial biodiversity hotspots. N ...
JAN 29, 2021
Earth & The Environment
The surprising sex lives of lichen
JAN 29, 2021
The surprising sex lives of lichen
Just like eavesdropping neighbors, scientists from Quebec's Université-Laval are peeping in on the shocking s ...
MAR 02, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Why apocalyptic discourse doesn't work when talking about climate change
MAR 02, 2021
Why apocalyptic discourse doesn't work when talking about climate change
NASA has predicted 15 inches of sea level rise by 2100. By that same year, the IPCC predicts atmospheric CO2 concentrati ...
MAR 24, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Setting "zero" at zero, once and for all
MAR 24, 2021
Setting "zero" at zero, once and for all
New research published in the Journal of Geodesy establishes a novel approach to measuring elevation – one th ...
Loading Comments...