JUL 25, 2018 7:46 PM PDT

Does location sharing hurt or help endangered species?

Does sharing the locations of rare and endangered species help or harm those species? That’s the question that scientists from the University of Sydney and the University of Queensland aimed to answer in their new study, which reevaluated the impacts of data sharing. What did they conclude? More species can actually benefit from the sharing of data than those that are harmed.

Let’s break down the two sides. Conventionally, conservations have argued that sharing the locations of vulnerable species gives poachers a leg up on the animals, making those on-the-brink species even more vulnerable. "It is undeniable that in some cases, poachers have used published data to hunt down rare animals for the illegal wildlife trade. And even well-meaning people like bird watchers and sight-seers can sometimes do damage when enough of them trample a patch of habitat. Which is why scientists and conservationists have continually called on location data to be turned off in nature photos to help preserve species," explains lead researcher Dr. Ayesha Tulloch. This is exactly what happened with the local extinction of the Chinese cave gecko.

But the Australian researchers argue that there are pros to sharing data locations of endangered species. "Species, like Australia's tiny grassland earless dragon, have received greater environmental protection because published data was available to show that they were in trouble," said Dr. Tulloch.

What Dr. Tulloch suggests is a compromise of sorts: a framework that gives researchers and conservationists different options on how to share and not share sensitive data. Based on information about poaching, illegal trade, and human disturbance, the framework allows for delicate distinctions that in the end, all aim to save wildlife lives. Giving an example, Tulloch explains, "There are a number of ways you can deal with that data, such as only showing locations in 100km grid squares, that could allow it to be published without putting those species at risk.”

But in the end, Tulloch and the nine organizations she collaborated with are clear about their goals. "The challenge is to share data in a way that avoids perverse outcomes such as local species extinctions from human exploitation. But stopping all data publishing is not the answer. Data publishing has also led to improved protection and conservation for many species. Good data helps conservation managers know where action is needed."

A photograph of Rafflesia, Malaysia's giant parasitic corpse flower, which lacks protected habitat to thrive in. Photo: University of Queensland

Sources: Science Daily, Nature Ecology & Evolution

About the Author
BA Environmental Studies
Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
AUG 05, 2022
Plants & Animals
New survey shows record amounts of coral in Great Barrier Reef
AUG 05, 2022
New survey shows record amounts of coral in Great Barrier Reef
Here’s a little good news for the day: certain areas of the Great Barrier Reef have the highest amount of coral co ...
AUG 27, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Looking Back in Space: NASA's Ranger Program
AUG 27, 2022
Looking Back in Space: NASA's Ranger Program
This series will explore historic space missions from the start of the Space Age to the present day, including both crew ...
SEP 02, 2022
Plants & Animals
Bumblebee Survival Negatively Impacted by Early Onset of Spring
SEP 02, 2022
Bumblebee Survival Negatively Impacted by Early Onset of Spring
Bumblebees have been all the buzz lately. Headlines abound about how bumblebee populations continue to decline across th ...
SEP 13, 2022
Cardiology
Extreme Weather Threatens Heart Health
SEP 13, 2022
Extreme Weather Threatens Heart Health
Both unusually cold and unusually hot weather have been linked to heart disease deaths.
SEP 21, 2022
Technology
Researchers Examine "Black Box" of Artificial Intelligence
SEP 21, 2022
Researchers Examine "Black Box" of Artificial Intelligence
In a recent paper presented at the Conference on Uncertainty in Artificial Intelligence, a team of researchers from the ...
SEP 22, 2022
Earth & The Environment
Scientists Demonstrate How Air Pollution Changes the Way Plants Communicate
SEP 22, 2022
Scientists Demonstrate How Air Pollution Changes the Way Plants Communicate
In a recent study published in the Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences, a team of researchers from F ...
Loading Comments...