AUG 16, 2018 06:38 AM PDT

Should we artificially block sunlight in order to cool down the planet?

New research from scientists at the University of California, Berkeley has set out to think more critically about an idea that perhaps you haven’t even heard of: injecting particles into the atmosphere to cool the planet in an attempt to mitigate the warming effects of climate change.

This idea of solar geoengineering the planet to become in essence shadier has gained momentum in some fields because it is thought that crops might be able to grow better in cooler temperatures. Yet, after analyzing the past effects of several Earth-cooling volcanic eruptions as case studies for their hypothesis, the UC Berkeley team concluded that any improvements in crop yields from cooler temperatures would be overshadowed (pun intended) by lower productivity due to reduced sunlight. After all, plants need sunlight to photosynthesize

"Shading the planet keeps things cooler, which helps crops grow better. But plants also need sunlight to grow, so blocking sunlight can affect growth. For agriculture, the unintended impacts of solar geoengineering are equal in magnitude to the benefits," said lead author Jonathan Proctor. "It's a bit like performing an experimental surgery; the side-effects of treatment appear to be as bad as the illness."

Photo: International Institute for Environment and Development

One of the volcanos that the team analyzed in order to come up with this conclusion was the eruption of Mt. Pinatubo in the Philippines in 1991. After this eruption, 20 million tons of sulfur dioxide were emitted into the atmosphere. That led affected the whole world by reducing sunlight by 2.5 percent and lowering the average global temperature by almost 1 degree Fahrenheit. Sounds pretty good in this epic wave of heat that we’re experiencing right now, doesn’t it? So why not just geoengineer something similar, using sulfuric acid aerosols?

"Unknown unknowns make everybody nervous when it comes to global policies, as they should," said Solomon Hsiang, co-lead author. "The problem in figuring out the consequences of solar geoengineering is that we can't do a planetary-scale experiment without actually deploying the technology. The breakthrough here was realizing that we could learn something by studying the effects of giant volcanic eruptions that geoengineering tries to copy."

This study only focused on the agricultural impacts of this solar geoengineering idea. While the scientists found that such a scenario would negatively affect both C4 (maize) and C3 (soy, rice and wheat) crops, they suggest that more research is needed in order to understand the consequences that solar radiation management would have on other global systems like human health or ecosystem function.

Sources: Science Daily, Nature

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
DEC 17, 2018
Videos
DEC 17, 2018
The 15 year-old who is taking the world by a storm
Fifteen-year-old environmental justice activist Greta Thunberg from Sweden took the climate talks at the COP24 summit by the horns with her barely over thr...
JAN 02, 2019
Chemistry & Physics
JAN 02, 2019
A "Nu" Way to Study the Impact of Microplastics
Microplastics particles (MP), often in the forms of fibers, beads, and pellets, are fragments broken off plastic waste. With a size no more than 5.0 millim...
JAN 15, 2019
Earth & The Environment
JAN 15, 2019
Scientific gaps in ocean warming research
Research published recently in PNAS attempts to shed light on the gaps in scientific knowledge regarding ocean warming. The team of scientists behind the s...
JAN 21, 2019
Plants & Animals
JAN 21, 2019
A Small Snake Eaten by a Larger Snake Turned Out to be a New Species
More than four decades ago, curious researchers carefully analyzed the stomach contents of a Central American coral snake that had been captured in Chiapas...
JAN 30, 2019
Plants & Animals
JAN 30, 2019
New Study Supports Idea That Sonar Causes Mass Stranding Events in Whales
The last several decades have seen an explosive uptick in the number of mass stranding events (MSEs) involving certain types of whales, prompting researche...
FEB 05, 2019
Earth & The Environment
FEB 05, 2019
Climate change is making Earth bluer
New research published in the journal Nature Communications suggests that higher water temperatures resulting from climate change will affect the compositi...
Loading Comments...