AUG 07, 2019 10:38 AM PDT

Should we geo-engineer a super volcano to slow climate change?

New research published in Geophysical Research Letters takes a deeper look on the potentials that solar geoengineering methods might hold for our future. The research comes from the Carnegie Institute for Science and was led by Ken Caldeira and Lei Duan from Carnegie, along with Long Cao of Zhejiang University and Govindasamy Bala of the Indian Institute of Science.

We have learned from past volcanic eruptions that the spewing of ash that is released into the atmosphere during an eruption has the capacity to greatly cool the planet. This is because ash and the other erupted particles reflect the Sun’s radiation, keeping sunlight from entering the atmosphere. During past eruptions of supervolcanoes, the aftermath of ash has even sent Earth into extended winter periods.

For some time now researchers have been contemplating several different methods of solar geoengineering as a means of reducing the effecting of climate change. These strategies involve intentionally emitting aerosol particles into the atmosphere to lower surface temperatures, essentially mimicking the after-effects of a volcanic eruption. Of course, these methods are strictly theoretical as of now, and scientists are cautious to even contemplate the unanticipated outcomes that such methods could cause. Yet, say the researchers behind the new study, understanding all of the consequences behind such an endeavor is crucial.

"Nobody likes the idea of intentionally tinkering with our climate system at global scale," said Caldeira. "Even if we hope these approaches won't ever have to be used, it is really important that we understand them because someday they might be needed to help alleviate suffering."

Caldeira and his colleagues aimed to determine whether it is possible to use naturally-occurring volcanic eruptions as a guide to understanding the potential consequences of solar geoengineering. Using sophisticated models, they compared the impacts of a single volcano event with those of a long-term geoengineering deployment, the difference being the amount of time that particles stay in the atmosphere.

Volcanic eruptions spew ash into the atmosphere, affecting surface temperatures. Photo: Pixabay

They found that independent of origin, particulate matter decreases surface temperature significantly and that both scenarios cause land to cool faster than the oceans. However, there is a distinction between the scenarios regarding precipitation: precipitation decreases more in the aftereffects of a volcanic eruption than following geoengineering.

"When a volcano goes off, the land cools substantially quicker than the ocean. This disrupts rainfall patterns in ways that you wouldn't expect to happen with a sustained deployment of a geoengineering system," explains lead author Duan.

These conclusions help us see the bigger picture of solar geoengineering and its potential. However, says Caldeira, "While it's important to evaluate geoengineering proposals from an informed position, the best way to reduce climate risk is to reduce emissions.”

Sources: Science Daily, Geophysical Research Letters

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
JUL 30, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Megadrought Brings Western US Lakes to Record Lows
JUL 30, 2021
Megadrought Brings Western US Lakes to Record Lows
The megadrought affecting the western United States is not letting up, even though the monsoon season has begun. The lat ...
AUG 15, 2021
Plants & Animals
The Killer Instinct of a Dainty Flower is Finally Exposed
AUG 15, 2021
The Killer Instinct of a Dainty Flower is Finally Exposed
The exotic Venus flytrap is a famous carnivorous plant that's easy to identify. But it seems that another carnivorous pl ...
SEP 09, 2021
Chemistry & Physics
"Shape-Shifting" Birds: Climate Change's Newest Outcome
SEP 09, 2021
"Shape-Shifting" Birds: Climate Change's Newest Outcome
A new study released last Tuesday highlights a surprising response to climate change: physical changes in animal mo ...
SEP 15, 2021
Plants & Animals
Using Food Waste To Make Rechargeable Batteries
SEP 15, 2021
Using Food Waste To Make Rechargeable Batteries
Back in 2010, the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) estimated that nearly 133 billion pounds of food went to waste, ...
SEP 22, 2021
Chemistry & Physics
Commercial Fusion Energy Could be Within Reach, Thanks to the World's Most Powerful Magnet
SEP 22, 2021
Commercial Fusion Energy Could be Within Reach, Thanks to the World's Most Powerful Magnet
Commonwealth Fusion Systems (CFS) announced this month that their new magnet might be the breakthrough needed to make fu ...
OCT 21, 2021
Chemistry & Physics
The Threat of Satellite Swarms
OCT 21, 2021
The Threat of Satellite Swarms
Gazing up at the night sky as a child, I loved to point out the satellites blinking in the night sky. Often, I could see ...
Loading Comments...