DEC 14, 2020 10:03 AM PST

The luck behind our survival

A study published in the Nature journal Communications Earth & Environment comments on the reasons why Earth has remained habitable for much of the planet’s existence. The answer, according to Professor Toby Tyrrell from the University of Southampton, has a lot to do with luck.

Why Earth has not fallen into a completely inhabitable state for over three billion years is a question that fascinates geologists and earth scientists. Given the planet’s predisposition to extreme climates – having experienced multiple intense ice ages and high-temperature eras over its history – it is a wonder that life still continues to survive, says Professor Tyrrell, who is a specialist in Earth System Science.

"A continuously stable and habitable climate on Earth is quite puzzling. Our neighbors, Mars and Venus, do not have habitable temperatures, even though Mars once did. Earth not only has a habitable temperature today but has kept this at all times across three to four billion years - an extraordinary span of geological time."

In contemplating this conundrum, Tyrrell modeled simulations of exoplanets in our galaxy that are similar to Earth, of which there are estimated to be billions. He wanted to see how 100,000 randomly different planets responded to random climate-altering events (such as asteroid impacts, solar flares, and major geological events) over a time period of three billion years.  The goal was to understand when and why planets would become uninhabitable.

The findings from these simulations could not have been more clear: most of the planets that stayed habitable throughout the simulated time period had a mere probability of doing so. Of the 100,000 planets that Tyrrell simulated, 9%, or 8,700 planets, remained habitable for the three billion year period at least once. Out of those 8,700 planets that were successful, roughly 8,000 were successful fewer than 50 times out of 100 and approximately 4,500 were successful fewer than 10 times out of 100.

Photo: Pexels

From these simulations, Professor Tyrrell explains: "We can now understand that Earth stayed suitable for life for so long due, at least in part, to luck. For instance, if a slightly larger asteroid had hit Earth, or had done so at a different time, then Earth may have lost its habitability altogether. To put it another way, if an intelligent observer had been present on the early Earth as life first evolved, and was able to calculate the chances of the planet staying habitable for the next several billion years, the calculation may well have revealed very poor odds."

This information is telling in the search for exoplanets that host life. While scientists are enthralled by the idea of the existence of “twin Earths” in the galaxy, Tyrrell explains that his findings suggest that while some such planets may have been habitable at certain moments in their history, most have likely lost their habitability due to chance events over billions of years. 

Sources: Communications Earth & Environment, Eureka Alert

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
SEP 13, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Soil erosion exacerbates global phosphorus shortage
SEP 13, 2020
Soil erosion exacerbates global phosphorus shortage
New research published in the journal Nature Communications reports on the global phosphorus shortage that the planet is ...
OCT 05, 2020
Earth & The Environment
The rising concern of aerosol particles
OCT 05, 2020
The rising concern of aerosol particles
A study from Colorado State University scientists provides insight into the resiliency of aerosol particles, particles f ...
OCT 12, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Improving activated powdered carbon to prevent algal blooms in drinking water treatment
OCT 12, 2020
Improving activated powdered carbon to prevent algal blooms in drinking water treatment
In a study published in the journal Water Research, researchers from The Korea Institute of Science and Technology ...
OCT 22, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Legacy chemicals found in migratory birds
OCT 22, 2020
Legacy chemicals found in migratory birds
A study published in the journal Environment International has found long-forgotten chemicals, called legacy chemicals, ...
NOV 24, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Sentinel-6 Michael Freilich will extend sea level monitoring
NOV 24, 2020
Sentinel-6 Michael Freilich will extend sea level monitoring
Days ago, a new satellite was launched from Space Launch Complex 4E at Vandenberg Air Force Base in California with the ...
JAN 01, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Reading the history of monsoons
JAN 01, 2021
Reading the history of monsoons
New data from river basins in the Asian Monsoon region reconstruct the histories of annual river discharge from 41 river ...
Loading Comments...