JUN 29, 2021 8:54 AM PDT

Are Hydropower Plants as Green as They Seem?

WRITTEN BY: Carmen Leitch

Hydroelectric plants are touted for their ability to provide so-called green energy, which aims to continue to satisfy power demands without damaging the environment. In the Amazon basin, many of these hydroelectric plants have been built along the region's vast river complex, sometimes overriding the concerns of local people. These dams don't burn fossil fuels, but underwater, their reservoirs cause flooded vegetation to decay, which releases millions of tons of the greenhouse gases carbon dioxide and methane.

Belo Monte Hydroelectric Development / Credit: Laura Castro Diaz

Run-of-river (ROR) dams, including Belo Monte along the Xingu River, were once thought to adress this issue with their smaller channels and reduced flow. But reseachers have been investigating the release of methane and carbon dioxide at Belo Monte during its first two years of use, and they found that the greenhouse gas emissions at the site have increased three-fold compared to before the reservoirs were filled. The findings have been reported in Science Advances.

Climate researcher Dailson Bertassoli's team studied methane and carbon dioxide emissions during Belo Monte's first two years of operation and compared the results to levels that existed prior to the reservoirs being filled, finding a threefold increase in greenhouse gas emissions.

"Once you have the flooding of dry land, the organic matter that was trapped in the soil starts to degrade," Bertassoli, a professor of geology and climate change at the University of Sao Paulo told AFP. Bertassoli had observed bubbling of gases at one of the reservoirs.

"Instead of a natural river, we now have a reactor that favors the production of methane," he explained.

The reservoirs that RORs rely on are still large, noted study co-author and climate researcher Henrique Sawakuchi; the largest of these reservoirs contain dead, white trees that stick out in the vast channels of stagnant green.

Study co-author and University of Sao Paulo professor Andre Sawakuchi suggested that when hydropower plants are being considered, two things should be kept in mind. The first is the impacts to local aquatic species, and the other is the societal effects on the indigenous people that rely on the river.

The efforts of environmental and indigenous groups prevented the Belo Monte project in the 1990s, but in 2011, an ROR plant was built there anyway. Forest had to be cleared for the development; land was flooded and natural river flow was manipulated. A different team of researchers has warned that the true cost of the dam has been grossly underestimated.

Andre Sawakuchi noted that the Amazon should flow without obstruction, and advised against disrupting the natural cycles with any kind of hydropower plant. The authors noted that if ROR dams are going to be built anyway, minimal vegetation should be flooded so as not to raise greenhouse gas levels.

"This is the pulse of the river," he said. "With a hydroplant, there is no more pulse."

A 2019 study by the Environmental Defense Fund indicated that hydropower plants can cause a range of environmental impacts. Some have enough organisms that absorb carbon to make them act as carbon sinks. Others, however, emit more than they take in, and could be worse than fossil fuels when it comes to climate impacts.

"There is no utopia here," Bertassoli said. "Especially for countries that look so hard at hydropower as a sustainable 'green' answer to their energy needs."

Sources: Phys.org, Science Advances

About the Author
  • Experienced research scientist and technical expert with authorships on over 30 peer-reviewed publications, traveler to over 70 countries, published photographer and internationally-exhibited painter, volunteer trained in disaster-response, CPR and DV counseling.
You May Also Like
JUL 17, 2021
Plants & Animals
Temperature drives body, not brain, size in human evolution
JUL 17, 2021
Temperature drives body, not brain, size in human evolution
New research has found that temperature is the main driver behind an increased body size throughout human evolution.
JUL 21, 2021
Cell & Molecular Biology
Human Contact Increases Antibiotic Resistance Carried by Galapagos Tortoises
JUL 21, 2021
Human Contact Increases Antibiotic Resistance Carried by Galapagos Tortoises
Even Giant Galapagos Tortoises, (seen here migrating in a photo by Juan Manuel García) are not safe from the world's ant ...
AUG 15, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
Stunning Connection Between Bear DNA & Human Language Groups Is Revealed
AUG 15, 2021
Stunning Connection Between Bear DNA & Human Language Groups Is Revealed
Incredible findings from the wilds of coastal British Columbia have shown how closely linked animals, humans, and the en ...
AUG 19, 2021
Plants & Animals
Protect Our Potatoes on Potato Day
AUG 19, 2021
Protect Our Potatoes on Potato Day
Happy National Potato Day! Potatoes are a delicious part of many foods for people across the globe, but what do you know ...
AUG 21, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Celebrate Honeybees and Beekeepers on National Honeybee Day!
AUG 21, 2021
Celebrate Honeybees and Beekeepers on National Honeybee Day!
The third Saturday in August, this year the 21st, is National Honeybee Day! The date celebrates honeybee keepers and all ...
SEP 02, 2021
Chemistry & Physics
The Future of Room-Temperature Superconductors
SEP 02, 2021
The Future of Room-Temperature Superconductors
It begins with two diamonds, a pinch of carbon, sulfur, and a whiff of hydrogen gas. The result is the world’s fir ...
Loading Comments...