OCT 12, 2016 8:53 AM PDT

Is a urine-powered generator invented by Nigerian school girls actually plausible?


Almost four years ago a group of Nigerian teens unveiled a urine-powered generator at Maker Faire Africa in Lagos. Duro-Aina Adebola (14) , Akindele Abiola (14), Faleke Oluwatoyin (14) and Bello Eniola (15) developed a system where just one liter of urine will provide six hours of power supply, a topic that comes up again recently because of all the disaster relief from Hurricane Matthew. But how does the generator work, and is it really plausible that pee-produced energy can be the answer to all our fuel problems? Most likely no, but read on to understand why.
 

Photo: Maker Faire Africa
 

Here’s how the urine-powered generator works, as explained by the blog on the makerfaireafrica.com website:

• Urine is put into an electrolytic cell, which separates out the hydrogen.
• The hydrogen goes into a water filter for purification, and then into a gas cylinder, which looks similar to the kind used for outdoor barbecue grills.
• The gas cylinder pushes the filtered hydrogen into another cylinder that contains liquid borax, in order to remove moisture from the gas. Borax is a natural mineral, commonly used in laundry detergent.
• The hydrogen is pushed into a power generator in the final step of the process.

A big drawback is that hydrogen poses an explosion risk. But the girls used one-way valves throughout the device as a safety measure.

Sounds scientific enough, right?

But Motherboard explains otherwise: “The machine is supposed work by filtering urine into water pure enough for the hydrogen to be extracted. That hydrogen is what powers the internal combustion engine in the generator that produces electricity. The only problem with this workflow is that it’s been widely proven that it takes more energy to split water molecules into hydrogen and oxygen atoms than the resultant hydrogen fuel is able to produce.”

Indeed, there are some definite roadblocks for the system (although one has to give credit for effort and ingenuity). However these young women aren’t the only ones who are pee-motivated.

Gerardine Botte, a professor of chemical and biomolecular engineering at Ohio University, is among those working on practical ways to make urine into a more useful hydrogen source, essentially by turning power into a byproduct of wastewater treatment. She comments on the girls’ project, saying it takes more energy to extract hydrogen from urine than you end up getting in return as electricity. The energy equation gets even more skewed by the inefficiency of the generator used in the girls’ project.
“At first glance, they’re not having a net gain in energy,” Botte says. “But I think it’s important to say that these little girls, trying to do something like this, deserve a lot of credit.”
 


Forbes writes about Botte’s own approach, which uses electrolysis of urea as a method of wastewater treatment. “She says her process for converting urine into potable water is more cost effective and more energy efficient than current wastewater treatment methods. Pure hydrogen is produced as a byproduct and can be used in generating electricity.”

“You cannot get net energy gain, but there is no more efficient way to get clean water from urine,” Botte says.

Botte founded E3 Clean Technologies in 2011 to work on scaling the process for use by municipalities and others. The U.S. Department of Defense is trying out a portable system from E3 at military bases in remote areas, as both a way to treat wastewater and generate power. The system, which Botte calls GreenBox technology, converts a soldier’s urine into drinking water.

Sources: Forbes, Motherboard, DailyTech, Collective Evolution, Maker Faire Africa, PR Newswire


 

About the Author
BA Environmental Studies
Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
AUG 06, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Ancient Mars volcanism created rare mineral
AUG 06, 2022
Ancient Mars volcanism created rare mineral
In a collaborative study slated to be published in Earth and Planetary Science Letters this September, planetary scienti ...
AUG 06, 2022
Earth & The Environment
Today in Science History: Most Complete Skeletal Remains of Neanderthal Still Tell a Story Today
AUG 06, 2022
Today in Science History: Most Complete Skeletal Remains of Neanderthal Still Tell a Story Today
114 years ago, the first and only nearly complete Neanderthal (Homo neanderthalensis) skeleton was found in a cave in Fr ...
AUG 08, 2022
Genetics & Genomics
This Weed is a Super Plant, Providing Insight Into Drought Tolerance
AUG 08, 2022
This Weed is a Super Plant, Providing Insight Into Drought Tolerance
You may have seen a 'super plant' growing in between the cracks of sidewalks. Portulaca oleracea is commonly known as pu ...
AUG 14, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Looking Back in Space: NASA's Pioneer Program
AUG 14, 2022
Looking Back in Space: NASA's Pioneer Program
This series will explore historic space missions from the start of the Space Age to the present day, including both crew ...
SEP 12, 2022
Earth & The Environment
Nature's 'Electric Grid' Uses Light to Accelerate Conductivity
SEP 12, 2022
Nature's 'Electric Grid' Uses Light to Accelerate Conductivity
In a recent study published in Nature Communications, a team of researchers led by Yale University discusses nature&rsqu ...
SEP 19, 2022
Space & Astronomy
Life on Earth: Could More of the Surface Be Habitable?
SEP 19, 2022
Life on Earth: Could More of the Surface Be Habitable?
In a paper recently published in The Astronomical Journal, a group of researchers upended two long-held scientific assum ...
Loading Comments...