APR 12, 2017 8:29 PM PDT

Should we mine for renewable energies?

Deep-sea mining. Sounds like an extreme sport, doesn’t it? And it just might be the next extreme mineral extraction process that humans have embarked upon, yet the topic of deep-sea mining is controversial because so little is known about seafloors. Although of course environmentalists are weary of tearing up the bottom of the ocean, Cindy Van Dover, both a pilot and scientist for the submersible Alvin, says that it’s difficult to extrapolate limited knowledge of certain sections of the seafloor to the entire thing.

“We know if they mine in some places they’re just going to rip up the seafloor, so to some extent we know that there’s some habitat destruction going on,” but she says, “There’s lots of unknowns. There are organisms that have very long lives. There are organisms that have very rapid reproduction that might seem resilient, but they live at hydrothermal vents so they’re really only endemic to small patch, and they’ll have to go find another patch.”

So sounds like the best option would be waiting to mine the seafloor until we know more about the impacts such mining will have, right? Well, that’s until you consider the recent treasure trove of rare minerals like tellurium that a team of British scientists found in an underwater mountain called Tropic Seamount. About 300 miles from the Canary Islands, the mountain stands about 3,000m tall with a large plateau almost 1,000m below the ocean surface.

Tropic Seamount in all its glory. Photo: NOC

With robotic submarines as their eyes and hands, researchers from the UK's National Oceanography Centre (NOC) found samples that contain tellurium in concentrations 50,000 times higher than in deposits on land. Dr. Murton, the man in charge of the mission, calculated that the 2,670 tons of tellurium they think to be there represents one-twelfth of the world's total supply.

But most importantly is what this substance can be used for. Tellurium is used in a type of advanced solar panel, and Murton estimates that if the entire deposit could be extracted and used to make solar panels, it could meet 65% of the UK's electricity demand.

Which brings us back to the dilemma: to dig or not to dig. In regards to this, Murton says: "If we need green energy supplies, then we need the raw materials to make the devices that produce the energy so, yes, the raw materials have to come from somewhere.”

But do they have to come from under the sea where so little is known, and where the marine flora and fauna have no one to stick up for them? To understand more, we can look at the currents around the seamount to help determine the impact that mining the area would have on marine life. Dust plumes from mining would follow the ocean currents, affecting all life within their range.

Professor Andy Gooday from the NOC reports that the range of life in the sediments of the deep ocean can be compared with that of a tropical rainforest and that "life on the ocean floor is more dynamic" than anyone expected. Recently a study in the Clarion-Clipperton Zone (near Hawaii) discovered 34 new marine species living on the bottom of the sea. Many bottom-dwelling species are single-celled organisms called xenophyphores that other species higher up in the food chain depend on for survival. It is thought that xenophyphores could be greatly impacted by dust plumes that would result from deep-sea mining.

"If you eliminate these xenophyphores, which are very fragile and would certainly be destroyed by mining, it would destroy habitat structure for other organisms. It's difficult to predict and, like everything in the deep sea connected with the effects of mining, we need to learn more – we still know so little about what's going on down there," Gooday says.

That’s why it’s so important to put strong regulations in place to begin with. We need to be the strict parent who then has the possibility of easing up, not the other way around. “Once they begin, it’s going to be like deep sea fishing, where it’s really difficult to manage,” says Van Dover. “I feel like we have this opportunity right now to get the regulations right.”

Sources: BBC, Popular Science

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
SEP 03, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Nuclear Pioneers Joined Force to Fast-Track Clean Energy Tech
SEP 03, 2020
Nuclear Pioneers Joined Force to Fast-Track Clean Energy Tech
Last week, TerraPower, a Bill Gates-backed nuclear startup, announced its latest project - a collaboration with GE Hitac ...
SEP 08, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Huge international supply chains account for 20% of global emissions
SEP 08, 2020
Huge international supply chains account for 20% of global emissions
This may come as a surprise to exactly no one, but multinational companies are the culprits of the highest levels of car ...
SEP 11, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Almost all forest fires are caused by humans, new study reports
SEP 11, 2020
Almost all forest fires are caused by humans, new study reports
New research published in the journal Fire reports that 97% of wildfires in the US that threaten homes are started by hu ...
SEP 18, 2020
Earth & The Environment
What does 0.5°C more mean?
SEP 18, 2020
What does 0.5°C more mean?
What is 0.5°C warmer anyway? It doesn’t sound like that much…right? Wrong. When the United Nations Fram ...
OCT 26, 2020
Cell & Molecular Biology
When Exposed to Estrogen, Fish Generate Fewer Males
OCT 26, 2020
When Exposed to Estrogen, Fish Generate Fewer Males
Life on earth relies on clean water, something that is becoming more scarce. Researchers have found that if water is con ...
DEC 04, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Fusions in Action: Scientists Confirm a Different Way the Sun Produces Energy
DEC 04, 2020
Fusions in Action: Scientists Confirm a Different Way the Sun Produces Energy
Since its formation, the Sun has been the main power source for all objects within its irradiation range, putting out 3. ...
Loading Comments...