DEC 31, 2017 10:53 AM PST

To drill or not to drill: the Arctic

Here’s something you may not have known that the new tax bill is hiding: drilling in the artic. Now, no matter your opinion on the new tax bill, did you realize that it would open up 2,000 acres of Alaska’s Arctic National Wildlife Refuge (ANWR) up to drilling for oil?

ANWR was first protected by President Dwight D. Eisenhower over 50 years ago and the refuge has since been hotly debated over. Home to 45 species of land and marine mammals and over 200 species of birds from all over the world, ANWR is about as biodiverse as the Arctic gets. One part of the refuge in particular on the coastal plain, called 1002 Area, has the most polar bear dens in Alaska and gives habitat to muskoxen, Arctic wolves, foxes, hares, dozens of fish species, and migrating waterfowl. 1002 Area is also home to the Porcupine Caribou herd’s calving ground. For the obvious reasons of wildlife conservation, all presidents and Congresses since 1960 have leaned towards continuing protection of “America’s last great wilderness.” Until now.

ANWR is home to the most polar bears in Alaska. Photo: The NY Times

As a part of President Trump’s plan to push oil, the tax cut seemed the perfect place to slip in this ANWR drilling provision, and it targets just that most biodiverse 1002 Area. According to the White House, oil lease revenues within the refuge is the answer to how to pay for the tax cuts that corporations and the uber-elite will receive with the new bill. The provision also helped get Alaska Senator Lisa Murkowski’s vote; she, along with many other Alaskans are pro-drilling because every state resident would get a yearly dividend from the federal royalty that comes out of the dollar value after oil extraction.

Murkowski is quoted as saying that drilling in the ANWR could generate $1 billion over 10 years from oil leasing. But that number is greatly disputed. According to the Center for American Progress, drilling in ANWR would likely yield no more than $37.5 million over 10 years. And that’s if leases for drilling actually sell. The price of oil is still relatively low and due to the high risks and costs of drilling in an area where there is limited transportation or infrastructure, oil companies may not see 1002 Area as the golden prize.

As one can imagine, this provision has environmentalists reeling. Though Murkowski has repeatedly said that the 2,000 acres of 1002 Area is just one-ten-thousandth of the entire refuge, environmentalists look to history to point towards the region’s extreme fragility. There has been one test well in ANWR; it has now been closed for 30 years and the landscape is still marked, despite attempts to heal the land.

Photo: Alaska Department of Natural Resources

Plus, there are the logistics of an oil spill in such a remote place. Clean-up of a spill would be severely limited by lack of infrastructure, extreme cold, and limited hours of sunlight. Were such a spill to occur, the plants and animals would likely be left to their own botched survival. Especially since the EPA recently got rid of the rule stating that mining companies have to clean up pollution.

One environmentalist put it this way: “You can have the oil. Or you can have this pristine place. You can’t have both. No compromise,” said Robert Mrazek, ex-chair of the Alaska Wilderness League.

Nevertheless, not all hope is lost for ANWR; proposals from oil leasing companies will be subject to intense environmental vetting and environmental groups are certain to put up a fight against said companies.

Sources: The Guardian, DeSmog Blog, Center for American Progress, LA Times

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
JUL 06, 2020
Earth & The Environment
The story behind a soil
JUL 06, 2020
The story behind a soil
Soil scientist Karen Vaughan from the University of Wyoming knows how to classify a soil well. There’s a science t ...
AUG 05, 2020
Plants & Animals
Scientists Discover Record-Breaking Rodent
AUG 05, 2020
Scientists Discover Record-Breaking Rodent
In a year of extremes, researchers have also unveiled a new record-breaking animal—the highest dwelling mammal on ...
AUG 14, 2020
Plants & Animals
Tracking the Iconic American Bison
AUG 14, 2020
Tracking the Iconic American Bison
The Great Plains of Montana are home to one of the United States' largest land restoration projects, known as the Am ...
AUG 21, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Earth's Outer Core, in the Middle of a Laboratory
AUG 21, 2020
Earth's Outer Core, in the Middle of a Laboratory
Deep underneath our feet lies Earth's outer core, a fluid layer over two thousand kilometers (1,500 mi) in thickness ...
SEP 18, 2020
Earth & The Environment
What does 0.5°C more mean?
SEP 18, 2020
What does 0.5°C more mean?
What is 0.5°C warmer anyway? It doesn’t sound like that much…right? Wrong. When the United Nations Fram ...
OCT 20, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Why the Weddell Sea is warming five times faster than the rest of the ocean
OCT 20, 2020
Why the Weddell Sea is warming five times faster than the rest of the ocean
New research published in the Journal of Climate finds that the Weddell Sea in Antarctica is warming five times fas ...
Loading Comments...