APR 26, 2015 10:43 AM PDT

'Disgust' Impression Lingers When Considering GMO Foods

WRITTEN BY: Will Hector
Perception is everything when it comes to certain debates. That could be why images of modified food have been so effective in the GMO debate.

To help explain why opposition to genetically modified organisms (GMOs) has become so widespread, a Belgian team of plant biotechnologists have turned to cognitive science. In a paper published April 10 in Trends in Plant Science, they argue that the human mind is highly susceptible to the negative and often emotional representations put out by certain environmental groups and other opponents of GMOs. The researchers urge the general public to form opinions on GMOs on a case-by-case basis, thereby not focusing on the technology but on the resulting product.

"The popularity and typical features of the opposition to GMOs can be explained in terms of underlying cognitive processes. Anti-GMO messages strongly appeal to particular intuitions and emotions," says lead author Stefaan Blancke, a philosopher with the Ghent University Department of Philosophy and Moral Sciences. "Negative representations of GMOs--for instance, like claims that GMOs cause diseases and contaminate the environment--tap into our feelings of disgust and this sticks to the mind. These emotions are very difficult to counter, in particular because the science of GMOs is complex to communicate."

Examples of anti-GMO sentiment are present around the world--from the suspension of an approved genetically modified eggplant in India to the strict regulations on GM crops in Europe. Contributing to this public opposition, the researchers suspect, is a lack of scientific understanding of genetics (not even half of the respondents in a US survey rejected the claim that a fish gene introduced into a tomato would give it a fishy taste) as well as moral objections to scientists "playing God."

"Anti-GMO arguments tap into our intuitions that all organisms have an unobservable immutable core, an essence, and that things in the natural world exist or happen for a purpose," Blancke explains "This reasoning of course conflicts with evolutionary theory--the idea that in evolution one species can change into another. It also makes us very susceptible to the idea that nature is a force that has a purpose or even intentions that we shouldn't' meddle with."

While religious beliefs, particularly those that hold a romantic view of nature, have been accused of generating some of the negativity around GMOs, Blancke and his co-authors argue that there's more to the story. Using ideas from the cognitive sciences, evolutionary psychology, and cultural attraction theory, they propose that it is more a matter of messages competing for attention--in which environmental groups are simply much better at influencing people's gut feelings about GMOs than the scientific community.

"For a very long time people have only been hearing one side," Blancke says. "Scientists aren't generally involved with the public understanding of GMOs, not to mention the science of GMOs is highly counterintuitive and therefore difficult to convey to a lay audience--so they have been at a disadvantage form the start."

The researchers believe that understanding why people are against GMOs is the first step toward identifying ways to counteract negative messages. Blancke and co-author Geert De Jaeger, a plant biotechnologist, started in their community by developing a public lecture to dispel myths about GMOs. They urge others to build science education programs that can help balance out anti-GMO campaigns.

"We want to bring the two sides more together," Blancke says. "You cannot say every GMO is bad. You have to look at each case separately to make a judgement."

Follow Will Hector: @WriteCompassion

(Sources: Cell Press; Science Daily)
About the Author
  • Will Hector practices psychotherapy at Heart in Balance Counseling Center in Oakland, California. He has substantial training in Attachment Theory, Hakomi Body-Centered Psychotherapy, Psycho-Physical Therapy, and Formative Psychology. To learn more about his practice, click here: http://www.heartinbalancetherapy.com/will-hector.html
You May Also Like
MAY 09, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
Another Neurodevelopmental Disorder is Discovered
MAY 09, 2021
Another Neurodevelopmental Disorder is Discovered
Researchers are identifying more rare disorders because of advances in genetic sequencing technologies, which have made ...
MAY 10, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
DNA Supercoiling is Found to Play a Role in Gene Expression
MAY 10, 2021
DNA Supercoiling is Found to Play a Role in Gene Expression
A cell has many ways to control gene expression, one of which is the structure of the genome itself; active genes have t ...
MAY 20, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
Mitochondrial DNA May be Affecting More Traits Than we Knew
MAY 20, 2021
Mitochondrial DNA May be Affecting More Traits Than we Knew
While the vast majority of our genes are in the genome that's held in the nuclei of cells, mitochondria are also known t ...
MAY 24, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
Lead Exposure Can Lead to Epigenetic Changes
MAY 24, 2021
Lead Exposure Can Lead to Epigenetic Changes
In Brazil, automotive battery plants use lead to make their products, exposing workers to the element, which is abundant ...
JUN 27, 2021
Cell & Molecular Biology
Organoids Reveal Common Mechanism Underlying Rare Disorders
JUN 27, 2021
Organoids Reveal Common Mechanism Underlying Rare Disorders
Genetic testing has shown that mutations in a gene called HUWE1 are connected to rare syndromes that cause developmental ...
JUL 04, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
New Insights Into the Mechanisms of Rett Syndrome
JUL 04, 2021
New Insights Into the Mechanisms of Rett Syndrome
Rett syndrome is a neurological disorder that mostly affects girls; affected individuals develop normally until they're ...
Loading Comments...