FEB 13, 2018 9:31 AM PST

Exonerating a Suspect in Cancer Causation

WRITTEN BY: Carmen Leitch

In research science, data doesn't stand on its own. Investigators build on the work of others, share their own findings, collaborate with one another, and reproduce the experiments of other labs. That ensures that hypotheses are subjected to rigorous tests before they are accepted as fact. A recent report about a gene called MELK has now called previous studies into question. Several labs had showed that this gene is overexpressed, or too active, in many cancerous cell types. That made MELK an attractive drug target for cancer therapeutics and prompted several clinical trials.

The growth of human colon cancer cells (raised in culture) is unaffected by the MELK gene. Top row: untreated cells; bottom row: cells treated with a MELK inhibitor drug. Left two columns, control cells; right two columns, cells in which MELK gene has been knocked out. CSHL researchers conclude that MELK is not involved in cancer proliferation.  / Credit: Sheltzer Lab, CSHL 

However, the new paper in eLife by researchers at Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory (CSHL) has found that MELK actually has no involvement in cancer. Led by CSHL Fellow Jason Sheltzer, the researchers suggested that the problem with the past studies was caused by flaws inherent to the techniques that were used to link the MELK gene to cancer.

"Our study is a good illustration of the self-correcting nature of science," Sheltzer said.

Over the past few years, Sheltzer has worked with Stony Brook University students Chris Giuliano and Ann Lin to analyze the genetics of tumors that had been removed from cancer patients. They wanted to find gene activity that was correlated with poor survival rates in patients. Then they aimed to use the CRISPR gene-editing system to follow-up on the genes they identified. One at a time, the genes would be removed from cancer cells to see how it affected the ability of the cancer cells to survive. 

MELK was one of the genes they tested. "Like other labs, we found that MELK tended to be very highly expressed in patients who did not survive very long," Sheltzer explained. Because the gene had been associated with cancer by so many other reports, they thought it would serve as a positive control for their research; removing it would be devastating to cancer cells if they needed it to grow as assumed.

"We thought we would eliminate MELK and show that it killed cancer cells. Then we could know that our CRISPR techniques were working," Sheltzer explained. "But, to our great surprise, the cancer cells didn't die. They just didn't care."

They repeated their work several times to be sure that the CRISPR tool was doing its job, and it was. "We eventually had to conclude that our technique was fine," Sheltzer noted. "Rather, it was the previous findings about MELK's role in cancer that were incorrect."

Sheltzer posited that some lab processes are prone to errors. They have unintended, or off-target, effects. RNA interference is one such tool; it is supposed to turn off genes very specifically, but it may not be as targeted as some scientists assume. "You think you're knocking down one gene, but in reality, those techniques are not very specific, so you're also hitting a number of other different genes," Sheltzer explained.

"We think that this might be a common problem," Sheltzer added. "There are likely other genes like MELK out there, and we're going to use CRISPR to find them."


Check out a talk from Sheltzer and Jennifer Doudna, one of the inventors of CRISPR, in the video above from CSHL.

Sources: AAAS/Eurekalert! via CSHL, eLife

About the Author
  • Experienced research scientist and technical expert with authorships on 28 peer-reviewed publications, traveler to over 60 countries, published photographer and internationally-exhibited painter, volunteer trained in disaster-response, CPR and DV counseling.
You May Also Like
MAY 10, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
Towards a Targeted Elimination of Leukemic Cells
MAY 10, 2020
Towards a Targeted Elimination of Leukemic Cells
Our blood carries many types of critical cells, including platelets, red blood cells, and white blood cells, which are m ...
MAY 10, 2020
Cell & Molecular Biology
RNA Structure Informs RNA Function
MAY 10, 2020
RNA Structure Informs RNA Function
Proteins carry out many of an organism's critical functions, and they are coded for by genes. To make a protein from ...
JUN 22, 2020
Cell & Molecular Biology
Viruses Can Create New Genes By Stealing Bits of Human DNA
JUN 22, 2020
Viruses Can Create New Genes By Stealing Bits of Human DNA
When viruses infect cells, they hijack the machinery inside and start to use it for their own purposes. This enables vir ...
JUN 01, 2020
Neuroscience
New Path to Gene Therapy for ALS
JUN 01, 2020
New Path to Gene Therapy for ALS
Video: Todd Cohen, PhD (UNC) discusses GA protein accumulation.  At the time of this video promising research was a ...
JUN 27, 2020
Microbiology
Learning More About How Bacteria Become Dangerous
JUN 27, 2020
Learning More About How Bacteria Become Dangerous
We have to share the world with microbes; they can grow almost anywhere, from hydrothermal vents deep in the sea, to the ...
JUL 03, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
Why Can Old Mothers Keep Producing Offspring?
JUL 03, 2020
Why Can Old Mothers Keep Producing Offspring?
The children of older mothers tend to have fewer children and have higher mortality. So why is it still biologically pos ...
Loading Comments...