JUN 18, 2019 2:13 PM PDT

Low Number of Vaccine Injury Claims Demonstrate Their Safety

WRITTEN BY: Tiffany Dazet

To spread awareness of vaccine safety, New York Times reporters Pam Belluck and Reed Abelson wrote a comprehensive report about vaccine injury claim data. Using information from the National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, they discovered that for every one million doses of all immunizations in the United States from 2006-2017, there were about two claims of injury.

The National Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (NVICP) was established by federal law in 1988 by the United States Health Resources and Services Administration as a result of the National Childhood Vaccine Injury Act of 1986. According to the NVICP’s website, the program’s objectives are to “ensure an adequate supply of vaccines, stabilize vaccine costs, and establish and maintain an accessible and efficient forum for individuals found to be injured by certain vaccines.”

In addition to the 15 childhood vaccines, the program also covers the seasonal flu shot. According to Belluck and Abelson’s research, many of the program’s payments in recent years relate to flu shots involving adults. From 2006 to 2017, more than 1.5 billion doses of the flu shot were administered, and fewer than 3,500 injury claims were filed. Their research shows that many of those claims were shoulder injuries not related to the formulation of the vaccine.

Belluck and Abelson reported that of the billions of vaccine doses administered in the United States in the past 30 years, only about 21,000 official injury claims were filed. Of the 85% of these claims (approximately 18,000) that were processed so far, only 6,551 received compensation while the rest were dismissed. Most of the compensated claims (70%) were settlements in which sufficient evidence of injury could not be linked directly back to the vaccine. According to the NVICP website, settlements may be negotiated “[if] both parties decide to minimize the risk of loss through settlement; [to] minimize time and expense of litigating a case; or [because of] the desire to resolve a petition quickly.”

The NYT reporters use measles as an example to demonstrate vaccine safety. They report that the data they analyzed shows that “the likelihood of serious harm if a person contract measles in much greater than the chance of being injured from the measles vaccine.” According to their research, one to two of every 1,000 people who get the measles are likely to die from it, and injury claims were filed for only two out of every one million doses of the measles vaccine.

Skeptics point to the existence of the program and the number of payouts given as evidence that vaccines are dangerous. However, public health experts such as Dr. H. Cody Meissner—who also serves on the NVICP’s advisory committee—consider the data as evidence of vaccine safety. As he told the New York Times reporters, “the overwhelming number of vaccine injections are completely safe and not associated with any adverse events.”

Sources: New York Times, HRSA

About the Author
  • Tiffany grew up in Southern California, where she attended San Diego State University. She graduated with a degree in Biology with a marine emphasis, thanks to her love of the ocean and wildlife. With 13 years of science writing under her belt, she now works as a freelance writer in the Pacific Northwest.
You May Also Like
JUL 11, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
Cocaine Changes Gene Expression in a Specific Part of the Brain
JUL 11, 2020
Cocaine Changes Gene Expression in a Specific Part of the Brain
Scientists have begun to examine how cocaine exposure alters gene expression in a specific region of the brain, and the ...
JUL 16, 2020
Immunology
Cancer Vaccine Charges Toward the Clinic
JUL 16, 2020
Cancer Vaccine Charges Toward the Clinic
Kristen Radford, a professor at Australia’s University of Queensland is among a scientific research team developin ...
JUL 21, 2020
Clinical & Molecular DX
A Lab on a Chip Could Save Your Life in an Emergency
JUL 21, 2020
A Lab on a Chip Could Save Your Life in an Emergency
Picture this: a hiker on a backcountry trail falls down a rocky embankment, and is left with a deep gash on the leg afte ...
JUL 21, 2020
Immunology
Hormone Therapies Keep Urinary Tract Infections at Bay
JUL 21, 2020
Hormone Therapies Keep Urinary Tract Infections at Bay
More than half of all women will suffer from a urinary tract infection, or UTI, during their lifetimes. Women are consid ...
JUL 29, 2020
Cannabis Sciences
CBD Tablets Help People Quit Cannabis
JUL 29, 2020
CBD Tablets Help People Quit Cannabis
Cannabis use disorder is essentially cannabis addiction. Although research suggests that it affects 9% of peop ...
AUG 06, 2020
Clinical & Molecular DX
Device Diagnoses Breast Cancer in 60 Minutes
AUG 06, 2020
Device Diagnoses Breast Cancer in 60 Minutes
Researchers have created a point-of-care device that can provide diagnostic results for breast cancer in under an hour. ...
Loading Comments...