APR 22, 2016 9:40 AM PDT

Animal Facility Temperature has a Huge Effect on Experiment Results

WRITTEN BY: Cassidy Reich
Are mouse research facilities at the right temperature? A recent opinion piece/review published in Trends in Cancer seems to think not. Authors Bonnie Hylander and Elizabeth Repasky from Roswell Park Cancer Institute have comprehensively reviewed the literature on the effects of ambient temperature on a variety of disease models and have concluded that temperature does have a significant impact on experimental results.

The National Research Council has set a guideline for mouse facilities to be kept at 20-26?, a comfortable working temperature for humans. However, the thermoneutral temperature for a mouse is much warmer, more like 30-32?. Thermoneutral temperature refers to the temperature at which an organism is expending the minimal amount of energy on temperature regulation. That temperature is much higher for mice than it is for humans and so mice in research facilities are constantly in a state of mild cold stress. When constantly exposed to cold, mice enter a state of “adaptive thermogenesis.” Adaptive thermogenesis is the process of increasing metabolic activity and heat generation by sympathetic nervous system norepinephrine (NE) release. The NE stimulates brown adipose tissue (BAT) activity. Unlike white adipose tissue, BAT is a thermogenic organ, like muscle. The increased BAT activity contributes to some of the changes between mice housed at normal animal facility temperature (sub-thermoneutral temperature, ST) and mice housed at their thermoneutral temperature (TT). Some of the differences are in basal metabolic activity, cardiovascular physiology, the size of organs, and tail length.

Some of these differences caused by ambient temperature have a huge effect on research results. Multiple studies in the field of obesity and neurobiology have shown that temperature can greatly affect results, which makes a lot of sense. If chronic mild cold stress stimulates BAT activity, the mouse will burn more energy at rest compared to a mouse at TT which will affect body weight. Basal metabolic rate can also affect neurobiology because the brain is such an energetically-demanding organ. Importantly, ambient temperature can also have an effect on inflammation and tumor growth. There has been a lot of research of tumor immunology in recent years, but mouse studies in this field might be less translatable to humans than previously thought. Mice at ST are less able to fight cancer compared to mice at TT. The mice kept at warmer temperatures have slower tumor growth and the tumors are less likely to metastasize, probably because the mouse is not under mild cold stress. However, ST can be beneficial for conditions that have an overactive immune system, such as graft versus host disease (GVHD). In that case, mice at ST are much more resilient against the disease than mice kept at TT.
 
The various biological processes affected by differences in ambient temperature.

There is overwhelming evidence that ambient temperature affects results in mouse models of various diseases and can skew the investigation of many different biological processes. But the main point that Hylander and Repasky wanted to make was not that all mouse facilities should be kept at a toasty 30?, but rather that temperature is an important variable. They hypothesized that some issues with reproducibility can be traced back to differences in temperature between labs. With the differential effects that temperature can have on different disease models, Hylander and Repasky have also pointed out that choosing a temperature to optimize the translatability of mouse studies to humans is something to consider when designing an experiment. As a researcher who works with mice, temperature is a variable that I have not really considered before, but after reading this, is one that I will have to pay much more attention to.
About the Author
  • Cassidy is a curious person, and her curiosity has led her to pursue a PhD in Pharmacology at the New York University Sackler Institute of Biomedical Sciences. She likes to talk about science way too much, so now she's going to try writing about it.
You May Also Like
JAN 14, 2020
Clinical & Molecular DX
JAN 14, 2020
Can I eat this donut? A quick test for celiac disease.
Genetic testing revealed that our ancestors have been eating wheat, rye, spelt and barley for over 8,000 years. Today, gluten, a protein found within these...
JAN 15, 2020
Cardiology
JAN 15, 2020
Burnout May Cause Heart Problems
At least 2.7 million Americans are affected by the most common variety of irregular heartbeat, known as atrial fibrillation (AFib). Now, new research has f...
JAN 15, 2020
Health & Medicine
JAN 15, 2020
The "Normal" Body Temperature Has Decreased
Did you know that the standard human body temperature of 98.6 degrees Fahrenheit was established in 1868? A few modern studies have called this figure into...
JAN 16, 2020
Health & Medicine
JAN 16, 2020
Babies in Africa Receive World's First Malaria Vaccine
Would you accept a vaccine that was only 40% effective? For those at risk of malaria, the answer is likely a resounding, "yes!" According to the...
JAN 20, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
JAN 20, 2020
Epigenetic Changes Make Breast Cancer Cells Drug Resistant
Researchers have found that changes in the structure of the genome in breast cancer cells can make them resistant to drug therapies....
JAN 22, 2020
Cannabis Sciences
JAN 22, 2020
People Struggling with Pain Also Struggle with Cannabis Use Disorder
The hype in the media that surrounds cannabis and health benefits supposedly associated with its use may be detrimental to individuals with certain conditi...
Loading Comments...