SEP 18, 2015 4:59 PM PDT

Antibacterial soap doesn't live up to the hype

WRITTEN BY: Kerry Evans
Did you wash your hands today?  Did you use antibacterial soap?  If so, you probably didn’t get the antibacterial benefits you expected.  Sorry.

Researchers from South Korea published a study testing the “real world” effectiveness of antibacterial soap.  The results?  Regular soap was just as effective at eliminating bacteria as soap containing Triclosan, the active ingredient in many antibacterial products, when tested under real world hand washing conditions.

Regular soap is just as effective as antibacterial soap at eliminating bacteria.

Triclosan is a polychloro phenoxy phenol antimicrobial that was developed in the 1960s.  At the low concentrations used in commercial products (up to 0.3%), Triclosan targets a bacterial enzyme necessary for fatty acid synthesis.  It is the most widely used antimicrobial in soaps and other products like toothpaste, shampoo, lotion, kitchenware, and even toys.  It’s also big business.  Americans spend nearly $1 billion on antibacterial soaps annually.  

The authors conducted their study in response to a 2013 statement by the FDA requiring manufacturers to demonstrate that antibacterial products are more effective than products without antibacterial additives. Not to mention, there are conflicting views (Aiello et al. and Montville and Schaffner) when it comes to the effectiveness of antibacterial soaps, and plenty of people are convinced that Triclosan itself is a health hazard (video below).

In this study, published in the Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, the authors tested antibacterial soap against regular soap in two ways.  First, they tested the ability of each soap to kill 20 different strains of bacteria under conditions that simulated hand washing.  Among these were species of Enterococcus, Staphylococcus, Pseudomonas, and Shigella.  For this experiment, they exposed the bacteria to soap containing 0.3% Triclosan for 20 seconds at either 22oC (room temperature) or 40oC.  In the second experiment, they inoculated volunteers' hands with Serratia marcescens and compared the antibacterial activity of each soap after actual hand washing.  After each experiment, the remaining bacteria were collected and grown on plates to count colonies of surviving bacteria.

Their results showed that Triclosan was more effective at killing bacteria than regular soap, but only after 9 hours of exposure.  (That’s a lot of hand washing.)  Overall, they found no significant differences between the antibacterial activity of Triclosan or regular soap under real world hand washing conditions.  

What’s the take home message?  The next time you’re out to buy soap, don’t bother with the antibacterial stuff.  It seems plain soap works just fine.



Sources: EurekAlert, Journal of Antimicrobial Chemotherapy, FDA, Wikipedia
 
About the Author
  • Kerry received a doctorate in microbiology from the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences.
You May Also Like
AUG 27, 2020
Microbiology
Underground Microbes Use an Ancient Form of Energy Production
AUG 27, 2020
Underground Microbes Use an Ancient Form of Energy Production
Organisms rely on a biological fuel known as ATP, which provides the energy for many processes. In cellular respiration, ...
OCT 26, 2020
Immunology
Gearing up for Life: The First 7 Days of the Immune System
OCT 26, 2020
Gearing up for Life: The First 7 Days of the Immune System
The mother’s placenta serves as a shield for the developing fetus inside the womb, protecting it from the constant ...
OCT 28, 2020
Microbiology
Immune Cells Link Gum Disease to Inflammatory DIsorders
OCT 28, 2020
Immune Cells Link Gum Disease to Inflammatory DIsorders
Scientists and clinicians know that oral health and inflammation, which is a part of many diseases, are connected.
NOV 09, 2020
Microbiology
Fighting COVID-19 with Help From Llamas
NOV 09, 2020
Fighting COVID-19 with Help From Llamas
Camelids, which include llamas, alpacas and camels have immune systems that generate two kinds of antibodies when confro ...
NOV 16, 2020
Cell & Molecular Biology
How Gut Microbes Deactivate a Common Diabetes Drug
NOV 16, 2020
How Gut Microbes Deactivate a Common Diabetes Drug
Metformin is a frequently prescribed type 2 diabetes treatment but its effects can vary significantly. In some patients ...
NOV 10, 2020
Neuroscience
Nanoparticles Pass the Blood-Brain Barrier in Zebrafish
NOV 10, 2020
Nanoparticles Pass the Blood-Brain Barrier in Zebrafish
Video:  Explains the challenges of delivering medicine to the brain, and possibly tools to pass the blood-brain bar ...
Loading Comments...