MAR 18, 2014 12:00 AM PDT

To Drink or Not to Drink, and How Much

WRITTEN BY: Jen Ellis
People do cost-benefit analyses in their heads on a daily basis, but don't bother to think about the brain mechanics behind their decision-making process. If you add consumption of alcohol to this scenario, one would expect the process to get even murkier - given that many of us in our college days perceived the benefits of consuming alcohol in the short term and the costs in the long term (such as the next morning).

Scientists at the University of Georgia decided to apply the cost-benefit approach to help them identify the portions of the brain that are engaged in the process of weighing whether or not to drink alcohol, and how much to drink. By combining an actual scenario in a bar with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI), the researchers were able to track the neural pathways involved in the different types of decision-making. Their work was summarized in a recent issue of Neuropsychopharmacology.

A study group of 24 heavy-drinking males between the ages of 21 and 31 were presented with a $15 credit at a bar, and were given decisions to make about the number of drinks they would consume at various prices, with the understanding that they could keep any money that was left over. During the decision making process, fMRI images were taken for later analysis. After the subjects made their choices, they were presented with the real drinks (up to eight) in the bar immediately afterward.

With this approach, the team was able to consider the neuroeconomic approach of the subjects - connecting psychology and economics to the underlying brain functions.

As the subjects decided whether to drink at all, sections of the cerebral cortex were activated (prefrontal cortex and parietal cortex). However, when economics was introduced and the subjects pondered how much alcohol and what type to drink based on the cost, the primary activation was in frontostriatial areas of the brain. These areas are involved in deliberation and mechanisms of reward, thus the researchers concluded some suppression was taking place from a higher cognitive burden.

The research team expected a higher level of activation regarding whether to keep the money or not drink at all, but instead they found that the cost-based decision of what type of alcohol and how much to drink produced greater activity.

As subjects weighed costs and benefits, their brain activity stayed high until they concluded the costs of drinking was too high. This makes intuitive sense - if you've decided you can't afford to drink anymore, there's not much cost-benefit analysis left to do.

However, the research team found that the anterior insula was active during times of higher conflict in the cost-benefit analysis. This area has been connected with motivational aspects of the brain in previous studies on addictive behavior. This leads to the possibility that this area is the meeting point between irrational and rational thought processes - in other words, the place in your head where the little devil on your right shoulder and the angel on your left shoulder live.

While there is always a chance this information can be used in a manipulative way (in other words, for advertising), the team hopes this research can be applied to the understanding of substances disorders and how to treat them. It may even be possible to distinguish differences in the brain scans of the normal casual drinker and the alcoholic. Let's hope the researchers win out over the advertisers.
About the Author
You May Also Like
OCT 25, 2021
Health & Medicine
Recognizing Dementia as a Risk Factor for COVID-19
OCT 25, 2021
Recognizing Dementia as a Risk Factor for COVID-19
Dementia is a cluster of neurological symptoms characterized by an impaired ability to remember, make decisions, and per ...
NOV 05, 2021
Cardiology
The Health Risks of Daylight Savings Time Changes
NOV 05, 2021
The Health Risks of Daylight Savings Time Changes
Research has suggested that policies aren't considered successes or failures on the basis of their merits. Daylight savi ...
NOV 17, 2021
Drug Discovery & Development
Native American Plant Extract Treats Pain and Diarrhea
NOV 17, 2021
Native American Plant Extract Treats Pain and Diarrhea
Plants with a long history of use as topical analgesics by Native Americans may also be helpful against diarrhea. The co ...
NOV 29, 2021
Health & Medicine
What is the Value of MRI After Acute Spinal Cord Injury?
NOV 29, 2021
What is the Value of MRI After Acute Spinal Cord Injury?
Your spine is made up of bones stabilized by multiple ligaments and muscles along its length. The spinal cord within the ...
DEC 10, 2021
Neuroscience
Cannabis Use Linked to Poor Sleep Quality
DEC 10, 2021
Cannabis Use Linked to Poor Sleep Quality
Recent cannabis use is linked to either less than 6 hours- short sleep- or more than 9 hours of sleep- long sleep. The s ...
DEC 13, 2021
Plants & Animals
A Plant-Based Diet May Lower Risk of Cognitive Impairment
DEC 13, 2021
A Plant-Based Diet May Lower Risk of Cognitive Impairment
It’s no secret that what we eat has a significant impact on our health, both physically and mentally. For example, ...
Loading Comments...