APR 02, 2014 12:00 AM PDT

Your Accurate "Inner Lie Detector"

WRITTEN BY: Jen Ellis
Can you tell if someone is lying to you or telling the truth? You probably can-but not for the reasons you think.

People have a tendency to look for stereotypical behaviors associated with lying, such as obvious nervous twitches, inability to look someone in the eye, fidgeting, or odd voice inflections. These traits may represent somebody who is innocent but nervous about being suspected of something. Conversely, people have been swindled in the past by smooth liars who have no problem with calmly looking their victims in the eye while they lie to them.

However, research has consistently shown that people are rather poor at detecting liars, with around a 54% accuracy rate in study environments. That is slightly better than guessing, or even flipping a coin.

A research team at the University of California-Berkeley discovered another mechanism people have that is superior at lie detection-automatic associations that are made within our unconscious minds. A summary of their research was published in a recent online edition of Psychological Science.

In their study, 72 people were asked to view a mock-criminal interrogation of suspects that were accused of a crime-in this case, stealing $100. While all of the suspects were instructed to tell the interviewers that they were innocent of the charge, some of them actually had stolen the $100 bill. Thus, the observers were given a group of liars and truth-tellers.

After the interviews, observers were asked to identify which of the suspects were lying and which ones were telling the truth. Their performance was relatively poor-only 43% of the liars and 48% of the truth-tellers were accurately identified.

The researchers then asked the observers to participate in a behavioral test known as the Implicit Association Test (IAT). The IAT is a test that measures unconscious associations, or instincts, through a series of rapid time-based association tests. By presenting photos of the suspects and forcing to choose between words to associate with the photo, the observers used their unconscious minds to determine who was likely telling the truth-and their unconscious minds performed quite well.

Words such as "Deceitful" and "Dishonest" were often correctly associated with the liars, while truth-tellers were more often associated with words like "valid" and "honest". Thus the unconscious mind outperformed the conscious mind.

The likely conclusion is that the more accurate assessments from our unconscious minds tend to be overridden by false assumptions, misconceptions, and biases in our conscious minds, similar to the stereotypical habits discussed above.

Another interesting finding of the study is no great surprise to those of us who are married. While all the unconscious efforts were better than the conscious ones, within the unconscious association results, female observers were significantly more accurate than male observers. Score one for "women's intuition".

So what does this mean? It means to consider your biases and stereotypes when trying to determine if someone is lying-and that you should probably give more weight to your instincts.
About the Author
You May Also Like
MAR 24, 2021
Cardiology
Supplement Can Prevent Strokes in Patients with Rare Disease
MAR 24, 2021
Supplement Can Prevent Strokes in Patients with Rare Disease
Scientists have found that it may be possible for people with a rare genetic disorder to prevent fatal strokes by taking ...
MAR 29, 2021
Cardiology
Learning More About How Stress Breaks the Heart
MAR 29, 2021
Learning More About How Stress Breaks the Heart
Scientists are learning more about what causes a real phenomenon known as broken heart syndrome, or stress-related cardi ...
APR 18, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
The Biology of Autism May Depend on Sex
APR 18, 2021
The Biology of Autism May Depend on Sex
It's been unclear whether boys are diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder more often because of detection issues, or if ...
APR 21, 2021
Neuroscience
Researchers Identify New Type of PTSD
APR 21, 2021
Researchers Identify New Type of PTSD
One of the biggest obstacles towards treating post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) comes from the different ways it exp ...
MAY 23, 2021
Neuroscience
Study Links Alcohol Consumption to a Decline in Brain Health
MAY 23, 2021
Study Links Alcohol Consumption to a Decline in Brain Health
Thinking of cracking open a cold one this weekend? Researchers from the University of Oxford have identified a connectio ...
JUN 05, 2021
Technology
Robotic Exoskeleton May Improve Response to Exercise-based Rehabilitation in People With Severe MS
JUN 05, 2021
Robotic Exoskeleton May Improve Response to Exercise-based Rehabilitation in People With Severe MS
Robots are most often found in science fiction. Recently, however, researchers are using robot-like technology to help p ...
Loading Comments...