DEC 10, 2014 12:00 AM PST

Chimps Fail To Gain Human Rights

In a landmark decision, the New York State Supreme court has failed to grant a writ of habeas corpus on behalf of a pet chimpanzee. The court ruled that while scientists may consider chimps to be cognitively similar to humans, they are not in fact humans and therefore not entitled to the same protections as Homo sapiens.

The suit was brought in December 2013 by the Nonhuman Rights Organization who sought to have Tommy, a 26 year-old chimpanzee who is being kept as a pet by a Gloversville NY couple, freed from captivity and sent to a sanctuary where he could be properly cared for. The Nonhuman Rights Project said in their petition that:

"Chimpanzees possess such complex cognitive abilities as autonomy, self-determination, self-consciousness, awareness of past, anticipation for the future and the ability to make choices; display complex emotions such as empathy; and construct diverse cultures. The possession of these characteristics is sufficient to establish common law personhood and the consequential fundamental right to bodily liberty."

The Nonhuman Rights project also argued that some non-human animals are indeed treated legally as humans such as pets who have been left large inheritances or made beneficiaries of trust funds. In addition, they stated that courts have long granted some human rights, such as free speech, to corporations.

In it's unanimous decision the court declined to extend habeas corpus to Tommy the chimpanzee and instead said that since New York law prohibits the possession of primates as pets, Tommy already has legal protection.

The Nonhuman Rights Project stated that the grounds on which the writ had been denied were "wrong" and that it plans to take Tommy's plight to the Court of Appeals. They also noted that they would be filing similar suits in two other New York jurisdictions seeking "identical relief on behalf of chimpanzees unlawfully detained."
About the Author
  • I'm a writer living in the Boston area. My interests include cancer research, cardiology and neuroscience. I want to be part of using the Internet and social media to educate professionals and patients in a collaborative environment.
You May Also Like
JUL 23, 2018
Plants & Animals
JUL 23, 2018
These Sneaky Monkeys Scavenge Nuts That Are Pre-Cracked by Predators
Throughout West Africa’s Taï National Park, the miniature mangabey monkey scavenges on the remnants of hard nuts that have been cracked open by...
JUL 25, 2018
Plants & Animals
JUL 25, 2018
Do Lizards Respond to Hurricanes With Rapid Natural Selection?
Do hurricanes induce rapid natural selection in tropical lizard populations? That's the latest idea that Harvard University researchers are bearing in mind...
AUG 21, 2018
Plants & Animals
AUG 21, 2018
Animals Have Changed a Lot Since Humans Began Breeding Them
People first started breeding animals about 10,000 years ago, and it’s safe to say that many bred animals have changed a lot since then. After people...
SEP 02, 2018
Genetics & Genomics
SEP 02, 2018
Insights From the Opium Poppy Genome
By sequencing the opium poppy's DNA, scientists have revealed important details about how it makes its medicine....
SEP 03, 2018
Plants & Animals
SEP 03, 2018
Two Newly-Discovered Dinosaurs May Explain a 70 Million-Year Evolutionary Gap
Dinosaur evolution is a hot topic in the scientific community because it can help us understand how and why modern animals came to be. Unfortunately, it&rs...
SEP 10, 2018
Plants & Animals
SEP 10, 2018
The WWF is Outfitting Tanzanian Elephants with Satellite-Trackable Collars
Animal poachers frequently target elephants because their ivory tusks can rake in a significant profit on the black market. But contemporary technological ...
Loading Comments...