SEP 25, 2017 12:09 PM PDT

New Laws Governing 'Shark Finning' Could Threaten Conservation Efforts, Marine Scientists Say

WRITTEN BY: Anthony Bouchard

In case you’ve never heard of the horrific practice called shark finning, it’s where people catch sharks, remove their fins, and then dispose of the de-finned shark by putting it back into the ocean.

The result isn’t pretty; the disposed of sharks almost never survive because they either bleed out from their wounds or can’t swim properly afterward. Why do people do it? – It turns out that shark fins are one of the essential ingredients for a type of soup that served throughout Asia, so it’s a profitable venture. Again, greed proves to be the root of all evil.

Conservation efforts of sharks are threatened by a practice called "finning," but new laws may threaten conservation efforts, scientists argue.

Image Credit: derwerbepool/Pixabay

Fisheries in the United States are a large part of the problem, mostly because current laws governing the practice are so spotty that people continue to get away with it. Nevertheless, other countries share the blame because many don’t regulate the practice at all.

It’s a nightmare for conservationists, but U.S. lawmakers are stepping up to the plate. A newly-proposed law could increase the severity of penalties for those owning or trading shark fins in the United States. Conservation groups like Oceana are backing the newfangled regulation, but not everyone thinks it’s going to help with conservation efforts.

Marine scientists David Shiffman and Robert Hueter share their concerns about the new laws, arguing that well-managed fishery systems would be more useful for shark conservation efforts than an outright ban in the United States.

They express their argument in a paper published in the journal Marine Policy.

Related: Here's why some sharks shrug their shoulders when swallowing

They suggest that moving away from managed fishery systems in place of strict bans would force those in the finning business to seek opportunities in unregulated countries instead. Unfortunately, because these countries don't regulate finning, the problem could potentially grow out of control and cause more harm to sharks than good.

"Removing that from the marketplace removes a template of a well-managed fishery," said Shiffman, a researcher at Simon Fraser University in British Columbia. "It's much easier for us to say, here's a way you can do this."

Related: Florida-based man faces charges after punching a hammerhead shark to death

Instead of opening the door for fin-snatchers to conduct their shady business in other countries, the scientists suggest that having a sustainable shark-fishery system in place in the United States is more important, as it would keep as many sharks in our oceans safe from finning as possible.

Shiffman’s idea would purportedly allow the market to continue functioning, but only under controlled capacities such that the practice wouldn’t put shark conservation efforts at risk. It's not a perfect solution to what's otherwise a heinous issue, but until the rest of the world starts regulating shark finning like the new U.S.-based laws will, it could be the only way to handle the problem efficiently.

All in all, the entire thing is a big mess. There is a whole host of factors involved in conserving sharks, but confusion runs rampant about the creatures' well-being because we don't know as much as about them as we'd like to think.

Researchers are doing everything they can to protect our ocean’s great fishes, but conservation regulation requires careful planning, and it’s entirely possible that lawmakers may not have thought this one through as well as they should have.

Only time will tell...


About the Author
  • Fascinated by scientific discoveries and media, Anthony found his way here at LabRoots, where he would be able to dabble in the two. Anthony is a technology junkie that has vast experience in computer systems and automobile mechanics, as opposite as those sound.
You May Also Like
DEC 01, 2019
Plants & Animals
DEC 01, 2019
Polar Bear Fights Are Sometimes for Fun, Other Times to the Death
Polar bears have a reputation as being one of the top predators in the Arctic, and with that in mind, it should come as no surprise to anyone that males ca...
DEC 09, 2019
DEC 09, 2019
Russian Cows Use VR Headsets to Increase Milk Production
Harsh weather conditions, particularly those found during winter months, are known to lead to a decrease in milk production among cows. To tackle this, Rus...
DEC 16, 2019
Genetics & Genomics
DEC 16, 2019
A New Threat to Christmas Trees is Discovered
Fraser firs are farmed to supply us with great-smelling Christmas trees that hold their needles, but they are also susceptible to molds....
DEC 27, 2019
Genetics & Genomics
DEC 27, 2019
How Dog Genomics Can Teach Us More About Human Health
It's been estimated that there are around 70 million pet dogs in the United States, with around 36 percent of households owning at least one dog....
JAN 30, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
JAN 30, 2020
New Infrared Spectroscopic Method Grants Scientists Unprecedented "Seeing" Power
Infrared spectroscopy is a popular scientific method to identify and study molecules based on their absorption of infrared light. Scientists at the Max Pla...
FEB 16, 2020
Plants & Animals
FEB 16, 2020
These Jellyfish Deliver Stings Without Touching You
Most people are accustomed to thinking that if you avoid a jellyfish’s tentacles while swimming in the ocean, then you won’t be stung. For the...
Loading Comments...