MAR 06, 2020 5:48 PM PST

Why Is Good Nutrition Advise So Hard to Come By

WRITTEN BY: Abbie Arce

Nutrition advice seems to come from everywhere. Exposure to this advice, one is likely to find endless examples of conflicting information. This happens for a variety of reasons and is influenced by a widespread of factors.

One such factor is that diets change over time. People today consume a very different diet than did their parents or grandparents. Many of the nutritional concerns of old have been mostly resolved. Conditions like scurvy and rickets were found to have links between them and specific nutritional compounds.

These conditions were each caused by deficiencies. Today, nutritional concerns are much less clear-cut. Deficiencies in modern diets are rare, and conditions generally have multiple factors contributing. Some modern dietary concerns with multiple influencing factors include diabetes, heart disease, and obesity. 

The second reason that nutrition is notoriously misunderstood is that it is impossible to conduct a perfect nutritional study. Ideally, for such a study, participants would live in a laboratory for a decade or so. They would all be fed identical diets, but one group would be fed the food or compound being studied.

This group would not know that they were receiving the food in question to avoid any placebo style effects. The food would be added in an unnoticeable way, for example, mashed into another food. 

Researchers would also be unaware of who is receiving the compound in question, allowing for unbiased, double-blind conditions. Additionally, participants would be barred from tobacco or alcohol use and be required to exercise in equal amounts. It is easy to see why such a study is incredibly unlikely.

This leaves researchers to use observational studies to look for links between a person’s diet and their current or future health. These studies, as they rely on self-reported data, are far from perfect. Not only may a person’s recall be imperfect, but persons reporting may also purposely neglect to mention certain dietary choices, like an entire sleeve of Girl Scout cookies.

Lastly, nutritional research is largely influenced by industry. While there is a clear issue with research grants coming from food giants like Coca-Cola, this funding is often considered critical for conducting such studies. 

The above video from Healthcare Triage looks into the flaws of one nutritional study to exemplify how even the best-intended journals promote, which is effectively, bad science. 

 

 

Sources: Public Library of ScienceHealthcare TriageScience Alert

About the Author
Applied Sport and Exercise Science
Abbie is an AFAA certified personal trainer and fitness instructor with an interest in all things health-science. She has recently graduated with her BS in Applied Sport and Exercise Science from Barry University in Miami. Next, she intends to earn an MPH with a focus in Epidemiology.
You May Also Like
APR 19, 2022
Cardiology
Daily Coffee May Improve Longevity and Heart Health
APR 19, 2022
Daily Coffee May Improve Longevity and Heart Health
Good news for coffee fans!
MAY 12, 2022
Plants & Animals
Coffee's Impact on Cholesterol Depends on Drinker Sex, Brewing Method
MAY 12, 2022
Coffee's Impact on Cholesterol Depends on Drinker Sex, Brewing Method
Coffee is one of the most popular beverages on the planet. Produced from the seeds of the Coffea plant, coffee beans are ...
JUN 09, 2022
Cardiology
Supplements and Heart Health
JUN 09, 2022
Supplements and Heart Health
There is little evidence that supplements actually improve heart health.
JUL 25, 2022
Cardiology
Drug that Can Help Men Live Longer?
JUL 25, 2022
Drug that Can Help Men Live Longer?
A new study from the University of Virginia School of Medicine and recently published in Science discusses how the loss ...
SEP 17, 2022
Drug Discovery & Development
Dental Care Linked to Better Heart Attack Outcomes
SEP 17, 2022
Dental Care Linked to Better Heart Attack Outcomes
People who receive periodontal care have shorter hospital stays following a heart attack. The corresponding study was pu ...
SEP 22, 2022
Cardiology
Lower Physical Function Is Associated with Heart Risks in Older Adults
SEP 22, 2022
Lower Physical Function Is Associated with Heart Risks in Older Adults
Low physical function has been linked to heart attack, stroke, and heart failure in older adults.
Loading Comments...