JUL 13, 2019 8:24 AM PDT

Problems In Diagnostics

WRITTEN BY: Abbie Arce

While the history of medicine is incredibly interesting, it is, in equal parts, entirely horrifying. In the past, everything from bloodletting, to the boring of holes into the skull, have been prescribed widely by medical practitioners. As we look back, it’s easy to consider these practices savage, but in their time, they were considered the highest standard of care. These failures in medicine go beyond treatments to the diagnostics that guide them.

The above video gives some insight into where early diagnoses came from and how practitioners were educated. 

While some diagnoses were developed with patient health in mind, others were developed for the purpose of control.

An example of this comes in the form of an 1897 diagnosis of “bicycle face“ written about in the National Review by Dr. Shadwell. This diagnosis was a measure hoping to discourage women from cycling, citing medical reasons. In his article, “The Dangers of Cycling “ Shadwell describes a strained facial expression as the main symptom of the disorder. This, he alleged, was the result of too much cycling, which over time was harmful to a woman’s appearance and desirability. 

While the diagnosis might seem funny today, it likely removed a healthy addition and convenient mode of transportation from the lives of many women. Additionally, it was undoubtedly an effort to reduce independence in women of the time.

In 19th century America, other invented conditions were used to control and justify the mistreatment of victims of slavery. Fictitious mental conditions were created with symptoms including laziness and an unlikelihood to follow orders. Lesions on the skin were also considered a symptom, although this was likely to help cover up abuse from slave owners. For the treatment of this condition, doctors recommended whipping.

More recently, we battle different harmful diagnoses. For example, homosexuality was still defined in DSM-1 as a “sociopathic personality disturbance.“ Shockingly, just last year, the WHO updated their International Classification of Diseases manual to no longer define transgender individuals as disordered. 

These examples highlight how regularly questioning our understanding of medicine is essential for providing a high standard of care.

To avoid the use of diagnosis to justify harmful practices, like conversion therapy, we need to be ever vigilant about the quality and implications of the diagnoses we hand down.

 

Sources: American Psychological AssociationCrash Course

About the Author
  • Abbie is an AFAA certified personal trainer and fitness instructor with an interest in all things health-science. She has recently graduated with her BS in Applied Sport and Exercise Science from Barry University in Miami. Next, she intends to earn an MPH with a focus in Epidemiology.
You May Also Like
MAY 06, 2021
Clinical & Molecular DX
Using Biology as Technology: A Paradigm Shift
MAY 06, 2021
Using Biology as Technology: A Paradigm Shift
Digital networks have changed the world by integrating into almost every aspect of our lives, but they have yet to direc ...
JUN 15, 2021
Cardiology
A Common Thread Among 20% of Sudden Cardiac Deaths
JUN 15, 2021
A Common Thread Among 20% of Sudden Cardiac Deaths
It's estimated that 450,000 Americans die from sudden heart conditions, and in about one in ten cases, the cause is unex ...
JUL 01, 2021
Clinical & Molecular DX
An Online Tool for Calculating Dementia Risk
JUL 01, 2021
An Online Tool for Calculating Dementia Risk
Picture this: You’ve misplaced your keys again and you no longer feel comfortable in social settings you once enjo ...
JUL 05, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
Genetics May Help Us Learn Who is at Risk From a Folate Deficiency
JUL 05, 2021
Genetics May Help Us Learn Who is at Risk From a Folate Deficiency
Folate is necessary for a healthy pregnancy; low folate levels can lead to neural tube defects. A lack of folate, a nutr ...
AUG 19, 2021
Cancer
Vitamin D Reduces Risk of Early-Onset Colorectal Cancer
AUG 19, 2021
Vitamin D Reduces Risk of Early-Onset Colorectal Cancer
Colorectal cancer (CRC) is the third most diagnosed type of cancer in both men and women in the United States and CRC in ...
SEP 08, 2021
Microbiology
Authorities Work to Contain Nipah Virus Outbreak in India
SEP 08, 2021
Authorities Work to Contain Nipah Virus Outbreak in India
Nipah virus is one of the world's deadliest viruses. It has caused several small outbreaks in Southeast Asia since it em ...
Loading Comments...