JUN 11, 2016 11:56 AM PDT

Technique to Make a Baby With Three Parents Deemed Safe

WRITTEN BY: Xuan Pham

The controversial new procedure to create “three-parent babies” could be approved and available by as early as next year. Researchers announced this possibility because they found evidence suggesting the procedure is safe and will result in healthy babies. But what is this procedure, and is it as safe as it seems?
 
IVF | Medical College of WisconsinKnown formally as mitochondrial replacement therapy or pronuclear transfer, this technique was developed as a way to produce a healthy baby that lack the sick mitochondria of the mother. As the proverbial ‘powerhouse’ of the cell, the mitochondria have their own set of DNA, which is derived solely from females. Thus, when a woman’s mitochondria are damaged or diseased, the chances of passing on these organelles to the baby can be quite high.
 
When damaged or mutated, abnormal mitochondria can cause several health conditions. These involve organs and tissues that consume high levels of energy, such as skeletal muscles, the brain, and the eye. And because the mitochondria are integral component of many biochemical processes, mitochondria dysfunction leads to a variety of metabolic diseases.
 
To help mothers with mutated mitochondria to have healthy children, researchers discovered that they could replace the diseased organelle, so to speak. In mitochondria replacement therapy (MRT), doctors use in vitro fertilization (IVF) to fertilize a mother’s egg (containing the bad mitochondria) with her partner’s sperm. When the embryo is still an undivided cell, doctors remove the nuclei and transfer the embryo’s DNA into a donor embryo, which is missing the nucleus.
 
Through switching organelles, the goal is to end up with a donor embryo (with healthy mitochondria) that has the essential DNA from the IVF procedure. The mother’s egg that contains the bad mitochondria is left behind. In theory, this prevents the mother from passing on her mutated mitochondria copies to her offspring. Because the procedure requires an embryo from a healthy donor, it’s often called the “three-parent baby” technique.
 


In a recent article, researchers from the UK say the procedure works and is safe. The researchers screened 500 eggs from 64 donors to assess whether the technique negatively affected the health outcome of the embryos. The team found that, indeed, replacing the sick mitochondria with healthy ones didn’t seem to hinder the embryos’ development. Furthermore, the procedure dramatically decreased the passage of unhealthy mitochondria to the embryos.
 
“This study using normal human eggs is a major advance in our work towards preventing transmission of mitochondrial DNA disease. The key message is that we have found no evidence the technique is unsafe. Embryos created by this technique have all the characteristics to lead to a pregnancy,” said Doug Turnbull, director of the Center for Mitochondrial Research and co-study author.
 
But there’s more to the procedure that may conflict with Turnbull’s confidence. While the procedure is safe, it didn’t prevent transmission of the bad mitochondria perfectly. That is to say, during the pronuclear transfer to an “empty” donor embryo, some of the bad mitochondrial copies still made it over. Thus there is still a chance of passing on the mother’s mutated mitochondria to the baby.
 
The team said the faulty mitochondria are transmitted in less 2 percent of the time, which significantly decreases health risks for the baby. However, another study, published in May, argued that carryover of faulty mitochondria can multiply and eventually overcome the healthy donor’s mitochondria. This, they claim, is a pitfall of MRT that still hasn’t been addressed fully.
 
With more studies ongoing, the efficiency of MRT will hopefully increase. But right now, Turnbull and his team are moving toward seeking federal approval with the Human Fertilization and Embryology Authority (HFEA), which is the equivalent of the US Food and Drug Administration. If a license is granted for MRT, the procedure may be available to women as early as 2017.
 
“We are optimistic that the technique we have developed will offer affected women the possibility of reducing the risk of transmitting mitochondrial DNA disease to their children,” said Mary Herbert, professor at the Wellcome Trust Centre for Mitochondrial Research at Newcastle University, and senior study author. 

Additional sources: BBC, Independent UK, Science News

About the Author
  • I am a human geneticist, passionate about telling stories to make science more engaging and approachable. Find more of my writing at the Hopkins BioMedical Odyssey blog and at TheGeneTwist.com.
You May Also Like
JUL 31, 2020
Cancer
Using Electric Fields to Treat Brain Cancer
JUL 31, 2020
Using Electric Fields to Treat Brain Cancer
One of the great things about research is its creativity, which can lead to interesting experiments, odd but impactful i ...
AUG 01, 2020
Cardiology
Identifying Biomarkers for the Diagnosis of Diabetic Cardiomyopathy
AUG 01, 2020
Identifying Biomarkers for the Diagnosis of Diabetic Cardiomyopathy
Type 2 diabetes affects millions around the world.  By itself, it prevents your body from properly using sugars fro ...
AUG 06, 2020
Cardiology
Identifying a Prognostic Biomarker for Neurological Deterioration After a Stroke
AUG 06, 2020
Identifying a Prognostic Biomarker for Neurological Deterioration After a Stroke
Strokes are life-changing events that can cause a myriad of issues even after it is over. Plenty of tests, such as the n ...
AUG 23, 2020
Technology
Cyborg Technology Could Advance Diagnostics
AUG 23, 2020
Cyborg Technology Could Advance Diagnostics
Although it’s true, "cyborgs" are technically science fiction being the fact that they are part human an ...
NOV 10, 2020
Clinical & Molecular DX
No More False-Negatives: An Ultrasensitive COVID Test
NOV 10, 2020
No More False-Negatives: An Ultrasensitive COVID Test
A team of researchers has improved upon the current diagnostic methodology for COVID-19, making it significantly more ac ...
NOV 25, 2020
Cancer
Using RNA to Diagnose HPV Associated Cancer
NOV 25, 2020
Using RNA to Diagnose HPV Associated Cancer
Diagnostic tools are critical to modern medicine. They might be less exciting than a good therapy or drug, but doctors a ...
Loading Comments...