SEP 10, 2015 4:14 PM PDT

When It Comes To Taking On Greenhouse Gas Emissions, Carrots Beat Sticks

WRITTEN BY: Andrew J. Dunlop
When it comes to cutting greenhouse gas emissions, carbon taxes work. Many policy makers who are working on reducing greenhouse gas emissions therefore put their focus entirely on passing laws that put these taxes in place. But getting these laws passed and enforcing them, especially in the United States, is always a fight, mostly with the wealthy, powerful carbon producing industries. A new policy paper by Berkley researchers advocates a different path. The Berkley team’s position is that the best and ultimately the most expedient course for reducing green house gas emissions is not to focus first on enacting carbon taxes. They say policy makers should first concentrate on building broad political support for green policies by investing in clean-energy industries, rather than penalizing polluters.

A frontal assault may not be the best way to take on greenhouse gases.

The paper, published today in the journal Science, was written by a multidisciplinary team of environmental, legal, and political experts. Why is the Berkley team advocating this seemingly softer approach? Jonas Meckling, assistant professor in the Department of Environmental Science, Policy and Management, and the study’s lead author explains, "This paper is about how can we build political support for progress on climate policy, toward decarbonizing our energy systems. … We find that the more green industries form or expand, the stronger the coalitions for decarbonizing energy systems become. This runs counter to the prevalent notion that pricing carbon is the first-best choice in climate policymaking."

Though at first glance, green industrial policy may appear less efficient economically, the Berkley team explained that supporting clean energy policies builds political support, so that further down the line, when policy makers propose carbon regulations, and carbon taxes, which impose costs on polluting industries, they won’t be going up against them alone. They’ll be entering the fray with a broad coalition of interests, individuals, and entities on their side. 



“Basically,” says Nina Kelsey, a postdoctoral scholar at the Berkeley Roundtable on the International Economy and co-author of the paper, “if you can build political support and speed up the process overall by using less efficient but more powerful tools up front, you may still lower the total costs in the long run.”

The paper’s authors described a number of examples where this approach has worked before. They pointed out that in two-thirds of all countries such as Denmark and Germany, and states like California where some form of carbon pricing policy was successfully enacted, leaders had first implemented incentives for clean energy, which built the political support for green industry, which ended up being crucial for eventual de-carbonization.

The authors also outlined some strategies that are keys to building winning coalitions for this de-carbonization. The first is adopting sector-specific targeted policies. They cited rebates and subsidies for renewable energy as examples that provide concrete benefits to firms and households.

The second recommendation the authors made is focusing on direct policy measures like renewable portfolio standards and feed-in tariffs, again policies that provide benefits for some rather than costs for others. Creating this sort of buy-in to green industry, says the Berkley team, will create constituencies who will support subsequent climate policy moves, such as an eventual imposition of a carbon tax.


Source: Phys.org
About the Author
  • Andrew J. Dunlop lives and writes in a little town near Boston. He's interested in space, the Earth, and the way that humans and other species live on it.
You May Also Like
AUG 12, 2021
Plants & Animals
Why Sunflower Heads Face East
AUG 12, 2021
Why Sunflower Heads Face East
You may have noticed that sunflowers can move their 'heads' or capitula to track the sun as its position changes during ...
AUG 15, 2021
Plants & Animals
The Killer Instinct of a Dainty Flower is Finally Exposed
AUG 15, 2021
The Killer Instinct of a Dainty Flower is Finally Exposed
The exotic Venus flytrap is a famous carnivorous plant that's easy to identify. But it seems that another carnivorous pl ...
AUG 22, 2021
Earth & The Environment
Fire Season in the Far North? The Wildfires of Siberia
AUG 22, 2021
Fire Season in the Far North? The Wildfires of Siberia
Fires have spread across over 10 million acres in Siberia
SEP 28, 2021
Earth & The Environment
How to Save the World's Coral Reefs? Global Reforestation
SEP 28, 2021
How to Save the World's Coral Reefs? Global Reforestation
With recent news of the world's coral supply standing at just 50% of what it was in the 1950s, any strategies for protec ...
OCT 06, 2021
Earth & The Environment
The Future is Fungi!
OCT 06, 2021
The Future is Fungi!
With more people looking to reduce the amount of meat they consume, vegetable substitutes for meat are on the rise. Thou ...
OCT 18, 2021
Cell & Molecular Biology
New Climatic Data from China Sheds Light on the Emergence of the Dinosaurs
OCT 18, 2021
New Climatic Data from China Sheds Light on the Emergence of the Dinosaurs
The climate is hot and muggy with the world's oceans as hot as a sauna. Also, it just started raining and it will not st ...
Loading Comments...