APR 18, 2018 03:43 PM PDT

Confronting the Lack of Science in Forensics

WRITTEN BY: Carmen Leitch

An editorial has been published in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences which highlighted the dubious nature of forensic investigations. People may not realize it, but many of the methods commonly used in both popular entertainment and criminal courts have never been validated scientifically. The authors note that people may have been unjustly convicted as a result.

Six scientists penned the editorial, independent experts who were a part of the National Commission for Forensic Science (NCFS), a now-disbanded panel that was terminated last year by the Department of Justice (DOJ). The authors want to reinvigorate interest in reforming forensic techniques. The video above from John Oliver discusses the issue in detail.

"We wanted to alert people that this is a continuing and a major issue: that many of the forensic techniques used today to put people in jail have no scientific backing," said senior author Arturo Casadevall, MD, Bloomberg Distinguished Professor and the Alfred & Jill Sommer Professor and Chair of Molecular Microbiology and Immunology at Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.

Forensic science has been hamstrung by bias; it is closely associated with law enforcement and prosecutors, the authors note. "Almost all publicly funded [forensic] laboratories, whether federal, state, or local, are associated with law enforcement. At the very least, this creates a potential conflict-of-interest," they said.

If you’ve seen a crime show, you’re probably familiar with the typical methods; detectives and forensics technicians gather fingerprints, bite marks, fibers, and tire or shoe tread patterns. Those methods have not been subjected to rigorous scientific scrutiny but became admissible in court cases. Fingerprint analysis is one area that has been updated to be more quantitative, but other tools have not.

"The forensic experts might claim, for example, that the fibers isolated from a body 'match' the fibers in a rug that was in the back of the suspect's truck, but generally they won't be able to say what the error rate in their conclusion is" Casadevall explained. "In other words, they haven't properly characterized the uncertainties involved in concluding that it is a match."

When DNA came on the scene in the 1990s, it showed that previous investigative techniques weren’t adequate. Many convictions have been overturned since genetic technologies have become a more reliable piece of evidence.

Genetic techniques have shown that many forensics methods are flawed. / Image credit: Pixabay

Congress tasked the National Academy of Sciences (NAS) with assessing the issue; a report was issued by their panel in 2009 that was highly critical of forensic techniques. They urged the DOJ to establish an independent entity to modernize forensic science.

The DOJ did go through with creating the NCFS, although they would not allow it to be a fully independent entity. It was administered jointly by the DOJ and the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST). But, political motivations were upended in the last presidential election, and the DOJ abandoned the effort.

"It's a shame - we had been making a lot of progress," Casadevall said. "Commissioners were realizing that in addressing these questions they might be able to improve their methods and the justice system."

Casadevall doesn’t expect the current administration to reestablish the NCFS. But efforts will be made to keep attention on the problem in the hope that in time, the DOJ will change its position. "We're hoping to keep the issue alive," he said, "and we can see that a lot of otherwise educated and well-informed people still don't understand the extent of the problem."


Sources: AAAS/Eurekalert! Via Johns Hopkins University School of Public Health, PNAS

About the Author
  • Experienced research scientist and technical expert with authorships on 28 peer-reviewed publications, traveler to over 60 countries, published photographer and internationally-exhibited painter, volunteer trained in disaster-response, CPR and DV counseling.
You May Also Like
OCT 22, 2019
Genetics & Genomics
OCT 22, 2019
A Combination of Genetic Mutations Often Seen in Endometrial Cancer is IDed
Powerful genetic sequencing technologies are helping researchers learn more about how changes or errors in genes are linked to disease....
OCT 22, 2019
Genetics & Genomics
OCT 22, 2019
How Much Do Genes Influence Sexuality?
A recent study has shown that there is no sigular ‘gay gene’ (Boyd: 2019). Instead however, it seems that there are multiple genetic factors th...
OCT 22, 2019
Genetics & Genomics
OCT 22, 2019
Investigating Previously Unmapped Regions of the Human Genome
Researchers have used cutting edge imaging tools to map a region of the human genome that has not been well-described....
OCT 22, 2019
Microbiology
OCT 22, 2019
The Microbiome is Affected by the Genome of Its Host
Many factors influence the composition of our microbiome, including our genes....
OCT 22, 2019
Immunology
OCT 22, 2019
New Observations of a Cancer Transcriptase
New research shows a transcriptase that helps time cell death varies in expression, and is unusually localized, in cancer cells.  The transcriptase, T...
OCT 22, 2019
Cell & Molecular Biology
OCT 22, 2019
Using CRISPR to Track and Image Genome Editing in Real Time
A team of scientists use fluorescently labeled proteins and CRISPR technology to image DNA transcription and chromosomal rearrangements....
Loading Comments...