APR 29, 2015 12:43 PM PDT

Mildly Misbehaved: NFL's Top Players Arrested but Not Charged

WRITTEN BY: Will Hector
Hamilton College Professor of Economics Steve Wu and 2012 grad Kendall Weir analyzed five years of NFL draft data and discovered that the performance of NFL players who had an arrest record but no charges was better than those without an arrest and those arrested and charged performed as well as those with clean records -- but they cost less. Those who had been suspended for another reason (violation of team rules, conflicts with coaches, etc.) performed significantly worse than those who had been arrested, whether charged or not. The study was published in the Journal of Sports Economics.

The pair's research finds that players with criminal records are being downgraded too much in the draft, and end up being a good value for the team because they outperform expectations. Weir and Wu collected data on more than 1,200 players and tracked their performance through the 2011-12 season. The results showed that players with "character concerns" were picked significantly later in the draft than otherwise similar players with no history of suspensions or run-ins with the law. In particular, players charged with a crime are picked about 15 spots (nearly half a round) later than similarly qualified players (measured by college career statistics and NFL combine results) who have no history of suspensions or legal problems. Players who were suspended for at least one game during their college career for violations of team or university rules are drafted roughly 25 spots later than otherwise similar players with clean histories.

Weir and Wu studied three categories of "character/behavior" issues:

1. Players who were arrested but not charged.

2. Players who were arrested and charged.

3. Players who were suspended for another reason (but not arrested -- these are primarily due to violation of team rules, conflicts with coaches, etc.)

These were all measured against players with a "clean" record -- i.e., no arrests, charges or suspensions.

"From the years we studied, the effect of categories 2 and 3 is that they are strongly downgraded in the draft, while those in category 1 are not significantly downgraded," says Wu. "The primary measure of 'performance' is average games started, and using this measure, those who have been arrested but not charged perform better than those with no arrests, charges or suspensions. Players who were arrested and charged perform no better or worse than 'clean' players. And those who have been suspended for another reason perform significantly worse than the 'clean' group."

Wu says the bottom line is that if a GM is on the fence about drafting a player who has been in trouble with the law, it's worth taking a chance on him because the statistics show he's likely to outperform players with no prior problems.

Follow Will Hector: @WriterWithHeart

(Sources: Hamilton College; Science Daily)
About the Author
  • Will Hector practices psychotherapy at Heart in Balance Counseling Center in Oakland, California. He has substantial training in Attachment Theory, Hakomi Body-Centered Psychotherapy, Psycho-Physical Therapy, and Formative Psychology. To learn more about his practice, click here: http://www.heartinbalancetherapy.com/will-hector.html
You May Also Like
DEC 15, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
Can a Brain Look Lonely?
DEC 15, 2020
Can a Brain Look Lonely?
Many isolated individuals have been isolated this year, and the holidays may only exacerbate feelings of loneliness.
DEC 23, 2020
Immunology
COVID Survivors Stay Immune for at Least a Year
DEC 23, 2020
COVID Survivors Stay Immune for at Least a Year
Once the coronavirus enters the body, the immune system springs into action, producing antibodies that bind to and neutr ...
DEC 28, 2020
Immunology
What Happens When Your Immune System Works Against You?!
DEC 28, 2020
What Happens When Your Immune System Works Against You?!
Our immune system is our army against any molecule that wants to invade our bodies like viruses, bacteria, and cancer. I ...
JAN 11, 2021
Cell & Molecular Biology
Ginger May Help Slow Lupus or Antiphospholipid Syndrome Progression
JAN 11, 2021
Ginger May Help Slow Lupus or Antiphospholipid Syndrome Progression
Naturally occurring chemicals make more appealing medicines for many people, but there is not always evidence that they' ...
JAN 19, 2021
Immunology
Food Allergies Be Gone: Nanoparticles Call for an Immune Ceasefire
JAN 19, 2021
Food Allergies Be Gone: Nanoparticles Call for an Immune Ceasefire
Milk, eggs, peanuts, tree nuts, wheat, soy, fish, and shellfish—these foods are among the most unwanted list for t ...
JAN 19, 2021
Cardiology
Risk of Atrial Fibrillation Raised by Daily Alcoholic Drink
JAN 19, 2021
Risk of Atrial Fibrillation Raised by Daily Alcoholic Drink
Some studies have suggested that moderate alcohol intake is linked to a lower risk of death from heart disease. But that ...
Loading Comments...