AUG 10, 2021 12:00 AM PDT

When Grandma's optimism bias gets in the way of perceiving COVID-19 risks

WRITTEN BY: Mia Wood

Should I have that second glass of wine? Is this car safer than that one? What if I don’t take the job offer – will something better come along? We take risks every day. Some are low stakes. Others are life changing. The profound impact of COVID-19 on all our lives — in particular, the culture war that ensued over masks and later, vaccination — brought the concept of risk front and center. For older adults especially, the risks are literally about life and death.

Early on, experts learned that the elderly were more at-risk for contracting COVID-19, and dying of it, than other age groups.  “As of February 2021, over 81% of COVID-19-related deaths in the US occurred in people over the age of 65,” according to a new study published in Nature Aging. Nevertheless, for many elderly people, thinking about risks been especially fraught. Why? Shouldn’t the risks associated with, for example, not masking or not getting vaccinated been obvious? A major contributing factor is optimism bias, the tendency to believe bad things won’t happen. Cognitive neuroscientist, Alyssa H. Sinclair, and colleagues developed an plan for increasing older adults’ perceived risk of viral transmission.

There are at least several factors that contribute to risky behavior in older adults. For example, older adults’ behavior is not always consistent with stated claims to being risk-averse. They also tend not to seek out information relevant to risk. Sinclair and colleagues found, however, that older adults more readily perceive the risk of COVID-19 transmission “after imagining a personalized scenario with social consequences.” Given that older adults are most susceptible to believing and sharing the volume of misinformation on social media, interventions need to “(1) effectively [convey] the risks of engaging in behaviors that could cause viral transmission and (2) [ensure] that risk information sticks over time.” Moreover, “personalized social information may help motivate older adults to improve risk literacy.”

According to Socioemotional Selective Theory, (SST), older adults, affected by the notion of increasingly limited time left in life, make decisions that “maximize emotional meaning, enhance social connections and emphasize personally relevant factors.” Sinclair’s study leveraged SST to generate “rich, personalized mental imagery about close others.”

546 participants aged 18-81 completed an online survey three times: Once before the imaginative exercise intervention, once after the episodic simulation intervention or control manipulation, and once between 1 and 3 weeks after. The 1-3 week follow-up survey found that participants aged 60-81 perceived greater risks than did both older participants in the control group and younger participants.

There are some outstanding questions, such as whether or not older people become generally more risk averse, regardless of the accuracy of the risk estimation. That said, such interventions may be effective in regulating optimism bias.

 

Sources: Wisconsin Public RadioNatureCDC Florida News Times

About the Author
  • I am a philosophy professor and writer with a broad range of research interests.
You May Also Like
AUG 28, 2021
Cannabis Sciences
Could Eye-tracking Data Detect THC Levels?
AUG 28, 2021
Could Eye-tracking Data Detect THC Levels?
Eye-tracking data shows promise for detecting levels of tetrahydrocannabinol (THC). The corresponding study was publishe ...
SEP 01, 2021
Technology
Keep 6 Inches Away: Smartphones and Watches Can Interfere With Implanted Medical Devices
SEP 01, 2021
Keep 6 Inches Away: Smartphones and Watches Can Interfere With Implanted Medical Devices
Recent guidance by the U.S Food and Drug Administration (FDA) recommended that people with implanted medical devices sho ...
SEP 05, 2021
Cardiology
Eating Walnuts & Pecans Can Help Lower 'Bad' Cholesterol
SEP 05, 2021
Eating Walnuts & Pecans Can Help Lower 'Bad' Cholesterol
Some nuts, especially walnuts, have high levels of healthy fats like Omega-3. New research reported in Circulation has s ...
SEP 11, 2021
Genetics & Genomics
New NIH Consortium Aims to Understand the Impact of Genetic Variants
SEP 11, 2021
New NIH Consortium Aims to Understand the Impact of Genetic Variants
Scientists sequenced most of the human genome abut two decades ago. It took many years to complete the project because o ...
SEP 14, 2021
Drug Discovery & Development
A novel drug that targets the removal of pathogenic antibodies in myasthenia gravis
SEP 14, 2021
A novel drug that targets the removal of pathogenic antibodies in myasthenia gravis
Myasthenia gravis is a chronic autoimmune disorder characterized by muscle weakness and fatigue. The disorder leads to a ...
SEP 15, 2021
Cardiology
Reducing Sugar in Packaged Foods May Protect Millions From Disease
SEP 15, 2021
Reducing Sugar in Packaged Foods May Protect Millions From Disease
For years, scientists have tried to learn more about whether addedor excess dietary sugars are harmful to a person's hea ...
Loading Comments...