DEC 11, 2014 12:00 AM PST

Isn

WRITTEN BY: Ilene Schneider
It is possible to detect when we provide false information regarding our health conditions through our handwriting, according to a new study conducted at the University of Haifa. The study used a computerized system, developed by Prof. Sara Rosenblum from the University of Haifa and patented recently, to analyze the handwriting process. "Our findings can provide the health care system and insurance companies with a fairly simple tool with which to discover medical fraud, without the need for intrusive devices such as the polygraph that tries to detect physiological changes," said Dr. Gil Luria, one of the study's conductors.

Medical fraud has become a common phenomenon in recent years. There are many cases of doctors encountering patients who want sick leave or compensation from the various health insurance providers, and who lie about their medical condition. The financial cost to health insurance providers in the United States due to false reporting is estimated at fifty billion dollars a year, not including the cost of wasted work days of doctors and the cost of the various tests performed.

In a previous study conducted several years ago, Dr. Gil Luria and Prof. Sara Rosenblum performed a pilot study of the computerized writing kit in which they found that deceptive and truthful writing in general can be detected. In their present study, performed together with Dr. Allon Kahana, the sample was increased significantly to include 98 participants. More importantly, however, this time the researchers chose to focus on testing the reliability of specific information - medical data - because of the difficulty that the health care system has in checking when patients are lying.

The participants were asked to write two paragraphs on the condition of their health, the first describing their real situation and the second describing fabricated medical symptoms. The participants wrote the two paragraphs on a computerized writing kit developed by Prof. Rosenblum that obtains data regarding the pressure being exerted on the page, the rate and speed of writing, the duration and number of times the pen remains raised in comparison with the duration and number of times it is touching the paper, the size of the letters and more.

This study shows that the system can identify when participants have written the truth and when they have lied. For example, the pressure exerted on the page when the participants were writing false symptoms was greater than when they were writing about their true medical condition. The regularity of the strokes when writing a lie, reflected in the height and width of the letters, was significantly different from the regularity of the strokes when writing the truth. Differences in duration, space and pressure were also found in false writing. The researchers were also able to divide the types of handwriting into more distinct profiles (very small or large handwriting) and to find other more substantial differences associated with each writing profile.

According to the researchers, when a person writes something false, cognitive load is created in the brain, and this load creates competing demands for resources in the brain, such that operations that we usually perform automatically, like writing, are affected. They added that the current study found that false medical information in "laboratory conditions" creates cognitive load that enables the computer system to identify changes in handwriting, and it can be assumed that in a natural situation, together with the need to lie to the doctor, the cognitive load would be even greater.

Even a doctor who is very knowledgeable will find it difficult to detect health fraud when a patient presents false symptoms from his field of expertise, so doctors are themselves trying to develop tools to solve the problem, however with very limited success. The writing kit provides a non-intrusive and simple testing device. Despite technological progress, handwriting is still the most common means used for daily communication, and we see clearly that every person has his own writing style. With a handwriting diagnostic kit, we can analyze whether the person is writing the truth or lies, the researchers concluded.
About the Author
  • Ilene Schneider is the owner of Schneider the Writer, a firm that provides communications for health care, high technology and service enterprises. Her specialties include public relations, media relations, advertising, journalistic writing, editing, grant writing and corporate creativity consulting services. Prior to starting her own business in 1985, Ilene was editor of the Cleveland edition of TV Guide, associate editor of School Product News (Penton Publishing) and senior public relations representative at Beckman Instruments, Inc. She was profiled in a book, How to Open and Operate a Home-Based Writing Business and listed in Who's Who of American Women, Who's Who in Advertising and Who's Who in Media and Communications. She was the recipient of the Women in Communications, Inc. Clarion Award in advertising. A graduate of the University of Pennsylvania, Ilene and her family have lived in Irvine, California, since 1978.
You May Also Like
MAR 18, 2021
Clinical & Molecular DX
"Hey Alexa, Are My Heart Rhythms Normal?"
MAR 18, 2021
"Hey Alexa, Are My Heart Rhythms Normal?"
Smart speakers—devices such as Amazon’s Echo and the Google Home—lend a helping hand around the house, ...
MAR 18, 2021
Cardiology
Searching for New Cardiovascular Biomarkers
MAR 18, 2021
Searching for New Cardiovascular Biomarkers
Do you want to know what the best medicine for cardiovascular health is? It isn't some heart-shaped pill with some m ...
MAR 17, 2021
Cell & Molecular Biology
A Critical Step in the Development of Brain Disease is ID'ed
MAR 17, 2021
A Critical Step in the Development of Brain Disease is ID'ed
Some brain diseases including mad cow disease and the human version Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD), Kuru, and fatal fam ...
APR 01, 2021
Health & Medicine
Flavanol-rich Foods Protect Heart from Stress
APR 01, 2021
Flavanol-rich Foods Protect Heart from Stress
Drinking hot cocoa is comforting on cold winter nights, and new research from the University of Birmingham shows that it ...
APR 04, 2021
Microbiology
A Nanoparticle-Based Universal Flu Vaccine Moves Closer to Use
APR 04, 2021
A Nanoparticle-Based Universal Flu Vaccine Moves Closer to Use
There are many different influenza viruses, which cause from 290,000 to 650,000 deaths every year. That range depends on ...
APR 12, 2021
Health & Medicine
Chronic Pain Patients Can Find Long-Term Success Using Cannabis
APR 12, 2021
Chronic Pain Patients Can Find Long-Term Success Using Cannabis
Many users report immediate pain relief from using medical cannabis, but now a recently published study suggests chronic ...
Loading Comments...