AUG 11, 2017 11:18 AM PDT

Plant-based vaccines?

WRITTEN BY: Kerry Evans

Until today, I had never, ever heard of a plant-based vaccine.

There are lots of reasons why plant-based vaccines are a good idea. Plants can churn out lots of recombinant proteins, and these proteins aren’t contaminated with animal proteins (or animal pathogens).

Some vaccines are made in lettuce

Image: Sean Gallup/Getty Images

Plants also make vaccine delivery pretty darn easy. No needle sticks required, just eat a handful of spinach leaves or some slices of potato! (French-fried vaccine, anyone?)

In some ways, plant-based vaccines are superior to those made in chicken eggs, for example. There’s no need to purify the antigenic proteins, and you don’t need specialized equipment to administer the vaccines. In fact, the immune response may even be superior. The antigens are carried to the intestines inside of plant cells. Once in the intestines, M cells take up the antigens and mount a systemic immune response.

In reality, though, there’s only one plant-based vaccine in commercial use - a Newcastle disease vaccine for poultry. While these vaccines aren’t quite ready for primetime, there are a number of clinical trials testing them in humans. Vaccines aside, there are other plant-based products already on the market. There’s human type I collagen that’s made by tobacco plants, bovine trypsin made by maize, and human lysozyme and lactoferrin made by rice.

So, what sorts of plant-based vaccines are in the pipeline? Let’s start with hepatitis B. The hepatitis B virus (HBV) is transmitted by body fluids and infects the liver. (Yes, there’s a traditional hepatitis B vaccine, but a plant-based one would be ideal for developing countries.) In one study, researchers produced an HBV surface antigen in lettuce. Human volunteers ate the lettuce leaves over 2 months, and the subjects produced transient levels of IgG. However, the vaccine didn’t produce significant levels of secretory IgA, which is required for effective protection.

Then there’s the flu. One problem with the typical flu vaccine is that production levels are limited - a 2011 report claimed that only 1.42 billion doses of the trivalent vaccine could be produced with chicken eggs.   

Luckily, research into plant-based flu vaccines has seen some success. This is probably because the haemagglutinin (HA) protein is expressed well in plants, and it folds properly. In fact, the virus-like particles (VLPs) produced by plant cells are more antigenic than the inactivated virus. One study tested the HA-containing VLPs in adults between 18 and 60 years old. (This vaccine was injected because flu is a respiratory pathogen.) Nearly 96% of participants mounted an immune response after vaccination, making plant-based flu vaccines appear promising.

Plants aren’t just good for making vaccines, they’re also good for making therapeutic antibodies. In 2012, the US Food and Drug Administration approved a therapeutic enzyme for Gaucher disease - glucocerebrosidase - that is produced in carrots. This plant-produced enzyme is actually better than the one made in animal cells because it is naturally mannosylated, a modification that helps it to be taken up by macrophages.

Nothing is without risk, however.

Oral plant-based vaccines may actually cause allergic reactions. In contrast, they may also induce oral tolerance by activating T-regulatory cells, essentially making the vaccine useless. As with all transgenic plants, there’s the issue of plants escaping the lab and passing recombinant genes on to wild plants. And, there’s also the chance that transgenic plants could be eaten by wild animals, producing unforeseen consequences.

Sources: Virology Journal, Plant Biotechnology Journal, and Journal of Botany

 

About the Author
  • Kerry received a doctorate in microbiology from the University of Arkansas for Medical Sciences.
You May Also Like
APR 01, 2020
Clinical & Molecular DX
APR 01, 2020
One dollar kit diagnoses COVID-19 in 10 minutes
Researchers have begun efficacy testing for a new SARS-CoV-2 diagnostic kit that claims to be able to test for COVID-19 ...
APR 22, 2020
Cardiology
APR 22, 2020
New Study Shows Red Meat May Not be Linked to Heart Disease
According to the Center for Disease Control (CDC), “heart disease is the leading cause of death for men, women, an ...
APR 22, 2020
Immunology
APR 22, 2020
Scientists Engineer Custom Antiviral Receptors to Fight COVID-19
The best offense may be a good defense in the fight against COVID-19. Researchers from the Duke-NUS Medical School are e ...
APR 27, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
APR 27, 2020
New Insight Into HIV Opens Path to Better Therapeutics
Researchers have made a breakthrough in our understanding of HIV infections.
APR 28, 2020
Microbiology
APR 28, 2020
Communities of Microbes Can Form 'Memories'
Microbes can grow in tight clusters called biofilms. These communities are tough, and have some of the same properties a ...
MAY 04, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
MAY 04, 2020
Molecular Tools Reveal More About the Impacts of the Slave Trade
Scientists still have a lot to learn about the numerous and varied consequences of the transatlantic slave trade, which ...
Loading Comments...