DEC 05, 2017 07:04 AM PST

Prisoner Wants His Brain Examined

An inmate on death row in Arkansas was granted a stay of execution last month in part because of a directive in his will that his brain be examined by neuroscientists after his death.

Jack Greene, convicted in the 1991 murder of pastor Sidney Burnett told his attorneys that he wanted medical examiners to conduct an autopsy and examination of his brain after his death. Greene and his attorneys have maintained that he suffers from severe mental illness as a result of his incarceration.

Death penalty law is complex and varies from state to state. However, the United States Constitution prohibits executing prisoners who are so mentally ill that they cannot form a rational understanding of their punishment. In Arkansas, state laws concerning the death penalty give the Department of Correction the sole authority to determine the severity of mental illness in prisoners who have been sentenced to death. Greene's attorneys argued that this policy effectively denied due process to Greene.

Greene's case has gone back and forth on the question of mental illness. Greene has told his attorneys that his treatment in prison has resulted in brain injury and dementia. His purpose in willing his brain to research after his death was to prove his mental illness. Greene's attorney, federal public defender Scott Braden, has cited many examples of his client's delusions, telling NBC News, "The state has taken the next step toward executing a man who suffers from severe mental illness. Mr. Greene has long held a fixed delusion that the Arkansas Department of Correction is conspiring with his attorneys to cover up injuries that he believes corrections officers have inflicted upon him. He complains that his spinal cord has been removed and his central nervous system has been destroyed. He believes he will be executed to cover up what he calls these ‘crimes against humanity'"

The case sheds light on the mental illness concern for many inmates on death row. Inmates who are sentenced to death at the state level are governed by the laws concerning the death penalty in the state in which their conviction was handed down. While some state death penalty laws have protocol in place to examine inmates and ensure they are mentally capable of understanding the punishment they have been given, Arkansas law does not require any mental health testimony, brain scans or medical information concerning the brain health of a death row inmate. The decision to carry out an execution in Arkansas rests solely with prison officials. Wendy Kelley, the Arkansas prison director responsible for deciding Greene's fate has stated that all the records have been reviewed and that the execution should be carried out. Greene's attorneys maintain that prison officials do not have the medical background and mental health expertise required to make an accurate decision on the intellectual or psychological disability of inmates. John Williams, another of Greene's attorneys, stated, "The system is really quite antiquated. Prison Director] Wendy Kelley is an arm of the state. She doesn't have the expertise to make that determination."

Greene was scheduled to be executed on November 9, 2017. However, the Arkansas State Supreme court issued a 5-2 ruling on November 8, 2017, granting an emergency stay of execution in a short one-page ruling that did not cite mental health concerns or any other reason for the ruling. Check out the video below for more information.

Sources: NBC News, CBS News, Reuters 

About the Author
  • I'm a writer living in the Boston area. My interests include cancer research, cardiology and neuroscience. I want to be part of using the Internet and social media to educate professionals and patients in a collaborative environment.
You May Also Like
JUL 31, 2018
Neuroscience
JUL 31, 2018
Draining the Brain Leads to Clues About Alzheimer's
Finding a way to reverse the aging process has been a goal for centuries. A "fountain of youth" seems to be the chupacabra of scientific research...
AUG 01, 2018
Health & Medicine
AUG 01, 2018
Let Food Be Thy Medicine: The Field of Nutritional Psychiatry
Many people eat a certain way to improve athletic performance. They choose low-carb or some other way of eating in hopes it might improve their mile time o...
AUG 15, 2018
Health & Medicine
AUG 15, 2018
Can Exercise Prevent Cocaine Addiction Relapse?
Addiction to drugs or alcohol is a medical problem that is difficult to treat. While there are medications and therapy to help, addiction changes the brain...
AUG 27, 2018
Neuroscience
AUG 27, 2018
A Korean Study Shows Gains in Head Size
The human body has evolved over time, and some of the changes have taken hundreds of years to show up. Evolution is a gradual process, and it took millions...
SEP 05, 2018
Videos
SEP 05, 2018
What makes a habit?
What is a habit? A habit is something that you do sub-consciously, whether it be something that you want to do or something you don't. But how do you f...
SEP 10, 2018
Neuroscience
SEP 10, 2018
Can Scientists Mimic The Effect of Exercise to Improve Memory?
Dementia is a growing problem for healthcare providers, patients, and families. The WHO estimates that globally more than 47 million people are living with...
Loading Comments...