APR 14, 2015 3:42 PM PDT

NASA Advisory Panel Suggests: Drop The Asteroid Mission, Let's Go To Mars

WRITTEN BY: Andrew J. Dunlop
You may have heard recently that NASA has been planning a mission to land on an asteroid, capture a bolder, and put it in orbit abound the Moon called the Asteroid Redirect Mission. This may have left you wondering, Is this really the best next mission for NASA? It may have left you feeling... less than inspired. Well, it turns out you're not alone. Last Friday, at the end of its most recent meeting, the NASA Advisory Council officially adopted a finding that the Asteroid Redirect Mission should be dropped, and that NASA should, instead use its new solar electric propulsion system for a mission that orbits Mars. The council said that the mission could still possibly include a sample capture, but why not capture a sample from one of Mars' moons, Phobos or Deimos?

Artist's conception of a solar electric propulsion spacecraft

Referring to solar electric propulsion, Steve Squyres, chairman of the advisory committee said, "if this technology is designed to go to Mars and back, let's send it to Mars and back." Squyers wasn't the only one on the council with this view. Their position was unanimous.

Here's some of the text from the council's recommendation:

"High-performance solar electric propulsion (SEP) will likely be an important part of an architecture to send humans to Mars. NASA's current plan is to demonstrate a large SEP stage by using it to maneuver a bolder that has been lifted from the surface of a small asteroid, and to move the boulder to cis-lunar space.

Maneuvering a large test mass is not necessary to provide a valid in-space test of a new SEP stage. We therefore find that a SEP mission will contribute more directly to the goal of sending humans to Mars if the mission is focused entirely on development and validation of the SEP stage. We also find that other possible motivations for acquiring an maneuvering a boulder (e.g., asteroid science, planetary defense) do not have value commensurate with the probable cost.

Instead of relocating a boulder from an asteroid, we suggest that a more important and exciting first use of this new SEP stage would be a round trip mission to Mars, flying it to Mars orbit and then back to the Earth-Moon system and into a distant retrograde lunar orbit."

There are a number of significant advantages of SEP over chemical rockets. First, it is about the tenth of the cost of a chemical rocket that could do the same job. Second, the energy source for SEP is the Sun, so as long as your craft is within the solar system, the fuel source is unlimited. Third, you don't have to haul all of that fuel into orbit with you. SEP is a slower propulsion method than chemical rockets, but as long as the mission is unmanned, capturing a boulder from one of Mars' moons or sending a cargo ship to Mars in advance of a manned mission, for example, this wouldn't really be a problem.

In order to change course and pursue a different mission may take some doing for NASA. There's a lot of political commitment that would have to be re-tracked. There's a whole mission that has already been set in motion. But, if, as the council points out, our goal is to go to Mars, it does seem as though pursuing a mission to Mars, as opposed to a mission to an asteroid is the straightest course.


(Source: NASA)
About the Author
  • Andrew J. Dunlop lives and writes in a little town near Boston. He's interested in space, the Earth, and the way that humans and other species live on it.
You May Also Like
NOV 02, 2020
Space & Astronomy
Never-Found-Before Molecule Detected in Titan's Atmosphere
NOV 02, 2020
Never-Found-Before Molecule Detected in Titan's Atmosphere
Astronomers have detected Cyclopropenylidene (C3H2) on Titan, one of Saturn's 53 confirmed moons. While the molecule ...
DEC 19, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Advanced Chemistry Module to Aid Future Mars Exploration
DEC 19, 2020
Advanced Chemistry Module to Aid Future Mars Exploration
Despite its resemblance to Earth, Mars, our planetary neighbor, is not exactly a friendly environment for human explorer ...
DEC 28, 2020
Space & Astronomy
During a Total Solar Eclipse, a Comet is Spotted Racing Past the Sun
DEC 28, 2020
During a Total Solar Eclipse, a Comet is Spotted Racing Past the Sun
On December 14, 2020, there was a total solar eclipse that could be seen in Chile and Argentina. Now scientists have rev ...
FEB 10, 2021
Space & Astronomy
Do Salt and Melting Ice Cause Landslides on Mars?
FEB 10, 2021
Do Salt and Melting Ice Cause Landslides on Mars?
Recurrent slope lineae (RSL) are dark flows that extend downhill on Mars to form sandy patterns on its surface. Research ...
MAR 08, 2021
Chemistry & Physics
Newly observed quasar jet sheds light on early galaxy formation
MAR 08, 2021
Newly observed quasar jet sheds light on early galaxy formation
New observations from the National Science Foundation's Karl G. Jansky Very Large Array (VLA) and Very Long Baseline ...
APR 21, 2021
Chemistry & Physics
New Pulsar Detected in Southern Hemisphere
APR 21, 2021
New Pulsar Detected in Southern Hemisphere
A new pulsar has been discovered with images from the Murchison Widefield Array (MWA) telescope, a low-frequency radio t ...
Loading Comments...