SEP 10, 2015 09:01 PM PDT

Cancer Testing vs. Cost

Should cost be a concern in cancer testing? Female carriers of mutated BRCA genes have a significantly higher risk for developing breast and ovarian cancers than those who do not. Nonetheless, a new study by UCLA faculty questions the value of screening for the genetic mutations in the general population — including those who do not have cancer or have no family history of the disease — because of the high cost.
About 7 percent of U.S. women will get breast cancer by age 70 (left), but 50 percent of women with a BRCA1 or BRCA2 mutation will. The mutation also increases the risk for ovarian cancer. 
The UCLA researchers found that compared with universal screening, other diagnostic tools remain more efficient and might be more cost-effective. The study, authored by Dr. Patricia Ganz, director of the division of cancer prevention and control research at UCLA’s Jonsson Comprehensive Cancer Center, and Elisa Long, assistant professor at the UCLA Anderson School of Management, was published online by JAMA Oncology
 
According to the researchers, the BRCA genetic test that is most widely used today is too expensive to warrant universal screening, given how rare BRCA mutations are. They think the cost would need to drop by 90 percent for testing to be cost-effective for the whole population.
 
The researchers calculated that for every 10,000 women screened, BRCA screening could avoid four cases of breast cancer and two cases of ovarian cancer more than family history-based testing would and that BRCA screening would only extend patients’ life by an average of two days. They said that for 99.75 percent of women screened, a negative genetic test offers no increase in life expectancy.
 
The UCLA study adds to work by other researchers that analyzed genetic screening of women of Ashkenazi Jewish descent. In that population one out of every 50 women carries a harmful mutation. A larger percentage of this group could be identified as BRCA mutation carriers, so Long and Ganz found that the approach would yield an estimated 62 breast and 34 ovarian cancers avoided per 10,000 women tested, and gains in life expectancy that were 16 times higher than with universal screening. Of the 233,000 breast cancers diagnosed annually in the United States, only 5 to 10 percent can be linked to mutations in the BRCA genes. Women with breast cancer who carry these mutated genes usually develop the disease at a younger age, often in both breasts, and the cancer is often a more aggressive sub-type such as triple-negative breast cancer.
 
As Ganz and Long explained, harmful BRCA gene mutations are more likely to be found in families affected by breast and ovarian cancers. Carriers can pass the mutated genes to both daughters and sons. Those who carry a BRCA mutation are believed to have a 45 to 80 percent lifetime risk of developing breast cancer. Women carrying the BRCA-1 mutation have up to a 39 percent lifetime risk; women with BRCA-2 have a 10 to 17 percent lifetime risk for ovarian cancer. The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force advises BRCA genetic testing only for women with a known family history of breast, ovarian, tubal or peritoneal cancer.
 
Long, who had no family history of breast cancer, has a personal connection to the BRCA-1 mutation. She is a carrier, and last year, at just 33 years of age, she was diagnosed with triple-negative breast cancer, the most aggressive form of the disease. She was treated with six rounds of chemotherapy, a bilateral mastectomy and reconstructive breast surgery. The chemotherapy killed the cancer before her first surgery, increasing her five-year survival probability from 60 to 95 percent. She also had her ovaries and fallopian tubes removed, reducing her risk of ovarian cancer to less than 5 percent.
 
She concluded, “On a personal level, I would have benefited tremendously from universal BRCA testing, because I had no family history of breast cancer, but as a health services researcher I must also consider the relative value of different medical interventions. Many patients wish to know more about their genetic risk factors, and as more firms begin to offer genetic testing, we should expect the price to decrease, eventually making this an affordable policy.”
 
About the Author
  • Ilene Schneider is the owner of Schneider the Writer, a firm that provides communications for health care, high technology and service enterprises. Her specialties include public relations, media relations, advertising, journalistic writing, editing, grant writing and corporate creativity consulting services. Prior to starting her own business in 1985, Ilene was editor of the Cleveland edition of TV Guide, associate editor of School Product News (Penton Publishing) and senior public relations representative at Beckman Instruments, Inc. She was profiled in a book, How to Open and Operate a Home-Based Writing Business and listed in Who's Who of American Women, Who's Who in Advertising and Who's Who in Media and Communications. She was the recipient of the Women in Communications, Inc. Clarion Award in advertising. A graduate of the University of Pennsylvania, Ilene and her family have lived in Irvine, California, since 1978.
You May Also Like
JUL 17, 2018
Cancer
JUL 17, 2018
Large Multifactorial NIH Study Announced for Prostate Cancer Aggressiveness in African-American Men
The largest coordinated study on Prostate cancer aims to look at both genetic and environmental factors that lead to increased risk and cancer aggressiveness in African-American men compared...
JUL 17, 2018
Cancer
JUL 17, 2018
Immunotherapy Diversification: From CAR-T cells to CAR-NK cells
New advances have made it possible for immunotherapy researchers to use natural killer cells, which are our body's normal defense for cancerous cells, to target tumors....
AUG 28, 2018
Drug Discovery
AUG 28, 2018
Combination Therapy for Advanced Melonoma
According to a research study led by UCLA, a bacteria-like agent used in combination with an immunotherapeutic drug may help patients survive longer with a...
SEP 26, 2018
Videos
SEP 26, 2018
Cancer Immunotherapy
Video illustration about how tumor cells are sensed and destroyed by the immune system and how tumors evolve and detect immune-mediated eliminations, as well as iimmunotherapies associated....
NOV 13, 2018
Immunology
NOV 13, 2018
Yin & Yang: The Duality of Cancer-Associated Fibroblasts in Pancreatic Cancer
Pancreatic Cancer is a devastating disease. Fifty-five thousand new patients were diagnosed this year in the United States (1). It is painful and usua...
DEC 09, 2018
Immunology
DEC 09, 2018
A Better Human Immune System: In Mice
We've cured cancer and autoimmune disease in mice many times over....
Loading Comments...