JAN 25, 2019 6:43 AM PST

Are Compostable Plastics Really a Green Substitute?

WRITTEN BY: Daniel Duan

The current trend to replace non-composable plastics such as polyethylene (PE), polypropylene (PP), or polystyrene (PS), with biodegradable ones, represented by polylactic acid (PLA), is based on the idea that the latter is better for the environment. But is it really the case?

PLA plastics can be decomposed by at least two genera of bacteria into its monomer lactic acid, and then carbon dioxide and water. The original process to make the polymer appeared over 20 years ago, but the cost for production was so high that it was not viable for large scale commercial applications for a long while.

Thanks to industrial chemist Patrick Gruber, who invented a more efficient way to produce PLA, the price for producing dropped almost 200 folds, bringing down the cost of one pound PLA to $1 dollar.

PLA plastics are made from renewable bio-sources, such as corn starch and cassava roots. Compared to petroleum-based plastics, producing PLA uses 65% less energy while generates 68% fewer greenhouse gases. Due to the high price of oil, biomass-derived PLA plastics have become more affordable. What's more, since PLA is non-toxic, it is a popular choice for making anything from food packages and containers to medical implants.

Related reading: the Pros and Cons of PLA Plastics

However,  this "guilt-free" substitute is not what it appears to be. PLA production depends on large fields of crops. But currently, a sizable portion of grain output has been dedicated to nonfood products such as ethanol. It will bring a big impact to food supply security and food cost if PLA were to gain more popularity and replace all other types of plastics. 

The environmental toll of industrially grown corn is another big concern. Corn farms often use more fertilizer, herbicides, and insecticides as compared to growers of other crops . The use of the chemicals can pollute aquatic bodies and erode soil, posing a threat to local ecosystems.

More detrimentally, because of their unique chemical nature,  PLA polymers (plastic label #7) should never be mixed in with traditional plastics (#1-#6) during the recycling process. They would degrade properly only in a dedicated composting facility. Studies have found that a majority of PLA plastics end up in the lands, where they cannot break down as fast and thorough as they are designed to do, making them no better than PE or any other form of oil product plastics.

So after all, the compostable plastics seem more like a band-aid solution to our environmental crisis. As many experts have called out for, eliminating single-use plastics is the ultimate fix to our problem.

Source: ACS Reactions via Youtube

About the Author
  • Graduated with a bachelor degree in Pharmaceutical Science and a master degree in neuropharmacology, Daniel is a radiopharmaceutical and radiobiology expert based in Ottawa, Canada. With years of experience in biomedical R&D, Daniel is very into writing. He is constantly fascinated by what's happening in the world of science. He hopes to capture the public's interest and promote scientific literacy with his trending news articles. The recurring topics in his Chemistry & Physics trending news section include alternative energy, material science, theoretical physics, medical imaging, and green chemistry.
You May Also Like
SEP 03, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Designing the most effective - and comfortable- face mask yet
SEP 03, 2020
Designing the most effective - and comfortable- face mask yet
Engineers from Georgia Institute of Technology have designed a facemask that is comfortable, safe, and – best of a ...
OCT 11, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
The mysteries of tiny surfing robots revealed
OCT 11, 2020
The mysteries of tiny surfing robots revealed
Mechanical engineers from Michigan Technological University have implemented the laws of surface tension and propulsion ...
OCT 18, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Monitoring ocean chemistry over the last forty years
OCT 18, 2020
Monitoring ocean chemistry over the last forty years
A study published recently in Nature Communications Earth & Environment contemplates the changing chemistry and ...
NOV 06, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
The Most Powerful X-ray Source On Earth
NOV 06, 2020
The Most Powerful X-ray Source On Earth
Located inside the Sandia National Laboratories in Albuquerque, New Mexico, the Z Pulsed Power Facility (or Z Machine) i ...
NOV 05, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Researchers describe a new rule for why fish swim in schools
NOV 05, 2020
Researchers describe a new rule for why fish swim in schools
A study published in Nature Communications highlights a new explanation of how fish swim in schools, a technique they us ...
NOV 12, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
Can a Chemical Be Both Nurturing and Destructive?
NOV 12, 2020
Can a Chemical Be Both Nurturing and Destructive?
On August 4, a megascale explosion almost leveled half of Beirut, the capital city of Lebanon. At the center of the negl ...
Loading Comments...