SEP 04, 2014 12:00 AM PDT

Is That Your Dog? It

WRITTEN BY: Peter Micheli
You've probably seen them. The pudgy wrinkled man walking his bulldog down the street, the lean elegant woman with her coiffed standard poodle. Researchers have long observed that people can match photos of dogs to their owners at a rate greater than pure chance would explain. But why? This holds true even when obvious reasons such as obese owners with obese dogs (The assumption being that they overfeed their dogs they way they themselves overeat.) are controlled for.

Dr. Sadahiko Nakajima, a psychologist from Kwasei Gakuin University in Japan set to find out why. He conducted a study involving 502 Japanese college students. They were shown two sets of 20 color photos of dogs and their owners on two sheets. The owners were men and women between 20 and 60 years old. The dogs consisted of wide range of breeds, including a Belgian tervuren, Yorkshire terriers, papillons, and golden retrievers. The dog and human faces were simple color headshots against a plain white background and digitally altered to be equal in size. One sheet shown to each participant was made up of real pairs of owners and their dogs. The other contained photos of dogs and people that were randomly paired.

Study participants were asked to "Choose the set of dog/owner pairs that most closely physically resemble each other." 80% of the observers were able to pick the set of photos that was made up of the real dog/owner pairs. But then Dr. Nakajima altered the photos so that a black bar obscured the owner's mouth. 73% of subjects were still able to select the set with the real pairs.

Covering the mouths didn't have a huge affect on results, but covering eyes did. The next sets of photos used pairs in which either the eyes of the human or those of the dog were covered by a black bar. In this case 52 percent of the subjects picked the correct set when the human eyes were covered, and 47% chose correctly when the dogs' eyes were obscured. This is about equal to what would be expected if they performed at a rate no better than chance (50 percent).

Next, the subjects were shown sets of photos where only the eye regions of both dogs and owners were visible. Amazingly, 74% of the judges were still able to identify the true set of dog/owner pairs. Nakajima was so surprised by this that he repeated this part of the experiment with a new group of subjects. This group did even a little better, with 76% of them picking the correct set of photos.

So, what does this study tell us? It indicates that people aren't using some obvious physical cues, such as weight, height, gender, hairstyle or eye color (All dog owners in the photo were of Asian descent and had dark-colored eyes) to match owners with their dogs. Rather, it seems to be all in the eyes. But, why is this? Even Nakajima can't explain what underlying mechanism is at work here.
About the Author
You May Also Like
OCT 05, 2020
Genetics & Genomics
A Rare Form of Dementia is Discovered
OCT 05, 2020
A Rare Form of Dementia is Discovered
There are different types of dementia, a term for a loss of cognitive function, including Alzheimer's disease and Le ...
OCT 05, 2020
Drug Discovery & Development
Fecal Transplants Could Restore Cognitive Function in the Elderly
OCT 05, 2020
Fecal Transplants Could Restore Cognitive Function in the Elderly
An international team of researchers has found that fecal transplants could one day be used to restore cognitive functio ...
OCT 21, 2020
Neuroscience
New Theory Says Consciousness Arises from Electromagnetic Energy
OCT 21, 2020
New Theory Says Consciousness Arises from Electromagnetic Energy
Professor Johnjoe McFadden, a researcher from the Univerity of Surrey in the UK, has proposed a new theory for conscious ...
OCT 30, 2020
Neuroscience
Why Older People Lose Motivation to Learn
OCT 30, 2020
Why Older People Lose Motivation to Learn
Researchers from MIT have identified a brain circuit that may explain why, as people age, they tend to lose motivation t ...
NOV 06, 2020
Clinical & Molecular DX
Your Earwax Says You're Depressed
NOV 06, 2020
Your Earwax Says You're Depressed
Cortisol, commonly known as the “stress hormone”, is the body’s built-in alarm system that sends siren ...
DEC 01, 2020
Neuroscience
Shorter Reinforcement Delays Make Neurofeedback More Effective
DEC 01, 2020
Shorter Reinforcement Delays Make Neurofeedback More Effective
Researchers at Russia's Higher School of Economics (HSE) have found that reducing delay in neurofeedback (NFB) signi ...
Loading Comments...