MAR 28, 2020 7:41 AM PDT

What's really important in organic agriculture

Agriculture takes up over a third of the land area around the globe. In the last several decades, the politicization of organic agriculture has become mainstream, with perspectives on both sides of the organic versus intensive agriculture becoming fierce. Recently, a study in Nature Communications claimed that organic agriculture is in fact worse for the climate because it ultimately uses more land to compensate for lower yields. The claim published in that study arrived at this conclusion by an analysis of the environmental impacts of agriculture and food through Life Cycle Assessment (LCA), the most common assessment method for such matters. However, in response to that study and the wide audience it received, a new study published in the journal Nature Sustainability argues that this perspective lacks the complexity of organic agriculture, and is thus unfounded.

This responding study comes from three researchers from France, Denmark, and Sweden who have taken it upon themselves to analyze the LCA system. They claim that the LCA method is overly simplistic and misses the benefits of organic farming.

"We are worried that LCA gives too narrow a picture, and we risk making bad decisions politically and socially. When comparing organic and intensive farming, there are wider effects that the current approach does not adequately consider," says Hayo van der Werf of the French National Institute of Agricultural Research.

The researchers say that LCA does not consider several key factors such as biodiversity, soil quality, pesticide impacts, and societal shifts.

"Our analysis shows that current LCA studies rarely factor in biodiversity, and consequently, they usually miss that wider benefit of organic agriculture," says Marie Trydeman Knudsen from Aarhus University, Denmark. "Earlier studies have already shown that organic fields support biodiversity levels approximately 30% higher than conventional fields."

Additionally, they are concerned that the LCA method concentrates primarily on product yields, evaluating environmental impacts per kilogram of product. This, they say, misses the bigger picture.

"LCA simply looks at the overall yields. Of course, from that perspective, it's true that intensive farming methods are indeed more effective. But this is not the whole story of the larger agroecosystem. A diverse landscape with smaller fields, hedgerows and a variety of crops gives other benefits -- greater biodiversity, for example," says Christel Cederberg of Chalmers University of Technology, Sweden.

Given the oversights in Life Cycle Assessment, the researchers are urging a revamping of the system. "Current LCA methodology and practice is simply not good enough to assess agroecological systems such as organic agriculture. It, therefore, needs to be improved and integrated with other environmental assessment tools to get a more balanced picture" says Cederberg.

Sources: Nature Sustainability, Science Daily

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
AUG 14, 2020
Plants & Animals
Tracking the Iconic American Bison
AUG 14, 2020
Tracking the Iconic American Bison
The Great Plains of Montana are home to one of the United States' largest land restoration projects, known as the Am ...
SEP 24, 2020
Plants & Animals
Cuvier's Beaked Whale Sets New Diving Record
SEP 24, 2020
Cuvier's Beaked Whale Sets New Diving Record
Marine mammals are uniquely adapted to dive to incredible depths. New research from Duke University Marine Laboratory do ...
SEP 24, 2020
Plants & Animals
High Arctic Polar Bears are Temporarily Benefitting from Climate Change
SEP 24, 2020
High Arctic Polar Bears are Temporarily Benefitting from Climate Change
For the past few decades, polar bears have been harbingers of climate change. However, not every polar bear subpopu ...
OCT 27, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Bird abundance falling in remote parts of the Amazon
OCT 27, 2020
Bird abundance falling in remote parts of the Amazon
A new study published in Ecology Letters has documented a consistent fall in biodiversity in the Amazon. The scient ...
NOV 13, 2020
Earth & The Environment
What the cylones of the past can tell us about the cyclones of the future
NOV 13, 2020
What the cylones of the past can tell us about the cyclones of the future
Research from the Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (WHOI) has reconstructed the patterns of historical tropical cycl ...
DEC 01, 2020
Earth & The Environment
Vegetation in poor countries isn't holding up as well to climate change as vegetation in rich countries
DEC 01, 2020
Vegetation in poor countries isn't holding up as well to climate change as vegetation in rich countries
New research from scientists at the University of Copenhagen's Department of Geosciences and Natural Resources Manag ...
Loading Comments...