JUN 21, 2016 10:40 AM PDT

Fitness band accuracy not always on target

Activity trackers can provide a good overall estimate of calories burned, but are less accurate when measuring certain activities, such as strength training.
 
"The key to a consumer is not so much if the activity monitor is accurate in terms of calories, but whether it's motivational for them and keeps them accountable for activity in a day," says Greg Welk

For a new study, researchers tested four consumer fitness trackers—Fitbit Flex, Nike+ FuelBand SE, Jawbone UP 24, and Misfit Shine—to see how well they measured sedentary, aerobic, and resistance activity. Two research monitors—the BodyMedia Core and Actigraph GT3X+—were also included in the study.

Overall, the BodyMedia Core was the top performer with a rate of error of 15.3 percent. The Misfit Shine was the least accurate with a 30.4 percent error rate.

Published in the journal Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, the study was designed to mimic real daily living activities. The 56 participants were asked to complete 20 minutes of sedentary activity, such as reading a book, working at the computer, or watching a video. That was followed by 25 minutes of their choice of aerobic activity and 25 minutes of resistance exercise, with 5 minutes of rest between each activity.

“By looking at the most commonly performed activities in exercise and daily living settings, we can examine where the errors occur,” says Yang Bai, lead author and a graduate research assistant in kinesiology at Iowa State University.

[related]

“As expected, some monitors overestimate or underestimate all three activities, but some monitors overestimate one type and underestimate the other two categories, which can cancel out if we don’t measure them separately.”

Researchers say accuracy is important, but it is only part of the equation in terms of improving physical activity levels.

“I think the key to a consumer is not so much if the activity monitor is accurate in terms of calories, but whether it’s motivational for them and keeps them accountable for activity in a day,” says Greg Welk, professor of kinesiology.

Source: Iowa State University

This article was originally posted on futurity.org.
About the Author
  • Futurity features the latest discoveries by scientists at top research universities in the US, UK, Canada, Europe, Asia, and Australia. The nonprofit site, which launched in 2009, is supported solely by its university partners (listed below) in an effort to share research news directly with the public.
You May Also Like
OCT 16, 2019
Space & Astronomy
OCT 16, 2019
LightSail-2 Spacecraft Demonstrates Viability of Solar Sails
The future of space travel looks bright, especially considering the fact that future deep-space probes could utilize passive solar sails to get to their de...
OCT 16, 2019
Clinical & Molecular DX
OCT 16, 2019
A Blood Drop Test for Rapid Detection of Traumatic Brain Injury
A study published by Yue et al., in August 2019, reported that a simple blood test (a few drops of blood) can detect traumatic brain injury efficiently and...
OCT 16, 2019
Chemistry & Physics
OCT 16, 2019
Prototype Generator Sucks Energy Out of "Complete Darkness"
The way the humankind harvest energy has come a long way. Our ancestors burned organic matters (tree branches, wax, and hays), and took advantage of the ki...
OCT 16, 2019
Cardiology
OCT 16, 2019
Clear, Flexible Vital Sign Wearable Monitors
Wearable health monitors are gaining in popularity, both for fitness tracking and for gathering more targeted health data relating to heart disease and oth...
OCT 16, 2019
Technology
OCT 16, 2019
Blood Incubation Using Laser Technology
The world’s first ever blood incubator was developed using laser technology and could someday prevent fatal blood transfusions in critically ill pati...
OCT 16, 2019
Chemistry & Physics
OCT 16, 2019
New Electrochemistry Warrants Million-Mile Worth of Battery Lifespan
It is no secret that Elon Musk, the mastermind behind Tesla and SolarCity, is betting on an electrified future for our society. But lithium-ion (Li-ion) ba...
Loading Comments...