NOV 28, 2018 9:37 AM PST

What critics think about the first gene-edited babies

Chinese scientist He Jiankui took advantage of the International Human Genome Editing Summit in Hong Kong to publicize the results of his Crispr-Cas9 trials, which he claims altered two babies’ DNA for HIV resistance. He modified the genes of baby girls Nana and Lulu in an attempt to mimic a natural mutation found in a small percentage of people which makes them resistant to HIV. He is now facing criticism from scientists around the world.

The Nobel laureate David Baltimore called He’s work irresponsible. “I think there has been a failure of self-regulation by the scientific community because of a lack of transparency,” Baltimore said.

Rice University, where He trained as a physicist, said the work "violates conduct guidelines of the scientific community and launched an ethics investigation". While the US and Europe have rules that prohibit this type of genetic modification on humans, China and other nations do not. Nevertheless, the outcries from the scientific community, calling He's work "immoral," "unconscionable," and "a genetic Russian-roulette" are surely just the beginning of this story. Stay tuned!

About the Author
  • Kathryn is a curious world-traveller interested in the intersection between nature, culture, history, and people. She has worked for environmental education non-profits and is a Spanish/English interpreter.
You May Also Like
NOV 05, 2020
Chemistry & Physics
No, Gravity Doesn't Affect How Bubbles Collapse
NOV 05, 2020
No, Gravity Doesn't Affect How Bubbles Collapse
The ubiquitous presence of bubbles makes them a common phenomenon, but interestingly our understanding of this globular ...
NOV 18, 2020
Plants & Animals
This Bat Species Uses Masks for Mating
NOV 18, 2020
This Bat Species Uses Masks for Mating
From pandemic precautions to televised talent shows, masks are having a moment. Even this bizarre bat species has a buil ...
FEB 19, 2021
Plants & Animals
What can Lemurs Teach us About Love?
FEB 19, 2021
What can Lemurs Teach us About Love?
Although not entirely accurate, romantic sentiments such as "you're my lobster" or "you're my pen ...
FEB 19, 2021
Plants & Animals
Group of Migrating Gray Whales Makes a Puget Sound Pitstop
FEB 19, 2021
Group of Migrating Gray Whales Makes a Puget Sound Pitstop
Washington’s Puget Sound is famously home to resident and transient orca pods. However, during their yearly migrat ...
MAR 03, 2021
Plants & Animals
Can Arctic Bearded Seals Compete with Human Noise?
MAR 03, 2021
Can Arctic Bearded Seals Compete with Human Noise?
Vocal communication is a primary key to survival for many species, including the Arctic Ocean's bearded seals. Accor ...
JUL 05, 2021
Plants & Animals
Why Are Some Fish Warm-Blooded? A Need for Speed
JUL 05, 2021
Why Are Some Fish Warm-Blooded? A Need for Speed
Great white sharks are warm-blooded, and new research helps explain why.
Loading Comments...