FEB 24, 2019 10:43 AM PST

Body Mass Index Scores Are Prone To Inaccuracy

WRITTEN BY: Abbie Arce

Body mass index (BMI) scoring is a highly problematic method of calculating a person's body fat percentage. The BMI chart has wholly neglected to acknowledge that every body is unique. It also doesn’t consider any difference in fat versus lean mass meaning someone who is exceptionally muscular might score as overweight or obese. Additionally, someone who started an exercise program very thin, and gained weight in muscle mass would score on the BMI as increasingly overweight. 

What BMI hopes to provide is a ratio of a person's fatty to lean mass. There are a number of ways this is done far more accurately in gyms and exercise science laboratories.

 

 

The first and perhaps most accessible of these methods are skin calipers. Costing about $10 a pair these can be found in most gyms. These tests can quickly and easily be done anytime, anyplace. These tools are used to measure the thickness of a number of skinfold sites throughout the body. Various protocols call for different numbers of testing sites, but they generally range from 3 to 7 areas on the body. In addition to being easily found in a gym, these tools can also be used for home testing with proper training on their usage. 

One of the downsides of this type of testing is the higher rate of variation between test sessions. It is essential that exercise professionals pinch and measure the same spot on the body each time they test.

 

 

The next method is called bioelectrical impedance (BI). These devices range significantly in cost and quality. The most basic being a handheld device that runs on batteries, again easy to find in many gyms. At the high-end of the spectrum, devices with multiple electrodes on a scale-type device often with handheld and other electrodes might be used. Although these devices may be accessible at the gym or purchased for home use, readings can be influenced by a variety of factors. These factors include water intake, recent meals and recent workouts all which alter readings. It’s recommended that people using this method of testing try their best to recreate the testing conditions of previous tests for optimal results. 

 

The next method is often considered the gold standard for calculating body composition. Hydrostatic weighing is a process by which exercise physiologists submerge a person entirely in water and compare their weight to their weight when immersed. This can be uncomfortable for test subjects who must force as much air as possible from their lungs and sit still while completely submerged. In addition to the discomfort, these tests are hard to find outside of very specialized gyms and exercise physiology labs. Even if they are available in your area, testing is expensive when compared with other techniques.

 

 

There are a few other techniques that may be used to measure body composition like a dual energy x-ray absorptiometry (DEXA) scan or an air displacement plethysmography both of which are highly accurate but even less likely to be found locally than hydrostatic weighing.

Whatever option is available to you, accurate body fat percentage measurements are important baseline measures. Not only can improvements be documented and celebrated, but these insights into changing body composition can also be incredibly motivating for exercisers on their journey towards a healthier weight. 

 

Sources: PolyfitHealth

About the Author
  • Abbie is an AFAA certified personal trainer and fitness instructor with an interest in all things health-science. She has recently graduated with her BS in Applied Sport and Exercise Science from Barry University in Miami. Next, she intends to earn an MPH with a focus in Epidemiology.
You May Also Like
JAN 26, 2021
Cardiology
Your Nose Could Tell You Something About Your Heart Health
JAN 26, 2021
Your Nose Could Tell You Something About Your Heart Health
As we get older, many things change in our bodies. We lose touch with the newest fashion trends, or which new phone is b ...
FEB 10, 2021
Cardiology
Finding the Link Between Air Pollution & Heart Disease
FEB 10, 2021
Finding the Link Between Air Pollution & Heart Disease
While many studies have shown that air pollution is linked to negative health impacts including poor cardiovascular heal ...
APR 14, 2021
Cardiology
Activity At Work Doesn't Benefit Like Leisure Time Exercise
APR 14, 2021
Activity At Work Doesn't Benefit Like Leisure Time Exercise
A new study that examined the habits and health conditions of thousands of people has suggested that exercise that's don ...
MAY 11, 2021
Cardiology
Red Blood Cells Could Help Predict Recovery in Cardiovascular Patients
MAY 11, 2021
Red Blood Cells Could Help Predict Recovery in Cardiovascular Patients
Cells are one of the basic building blocks of life. There are hundreds of different cell types, and they all work togeth ...
JUN 07, 2021
Health & Medicine
Higher Incidence of Breast Cancer in Polluted Urban Areas
JUN 07, 2021
Higher Incidence of Breast Cancer in Polluted Urban Areas
A Taiwanese study looked at the incidence of breast cancer in areas of Taiwan with varying levels of air pollutants. Air ...
SEP 07, 2021
Health & Medicine
Vaccines- a Long History of Cost-Benefit Analysis
SEP 07, 2021
Vaccines- a Long History of Cost-Benefit Analysis
Vaccination and new treatments for diseases have remained topics of skepticism since their inception. When it came to an ...
Loading Comments...